3 ms·
The biggest reason for cost overruns in the US is that the companies that are doing the work make more money from cost overruns. The way nuclear plant financing
by hristov 6y ago
The biggest reason for cost overruns in the US is that the companies that are doing the work make more money from cost overruns. The way nuclear plant financing works in the US is that taxpayers and ratepayers ultimately pay for the cost no matter what the cost is and how much the overruns are. The cost of the plant with all the overruns usually shows up on the electric bills of the consumers, so the more overruns the more one can charge the consumers. This overcharging may not happen fully intentionally, it may be happening as kind of a long bureaucratic slide into convenience but it is happening.
Now you may think there is an easy solution for this. Funding for these plants should be changed, so that private parties pay for them and they get their money by selling the electricity produced by the plants. I.e., they should be funded the way any private business is supposed to be funded in a capitalist economy. Sounds like a good idea at first, but there is a catch. If that is the rule, nobody in their right mind will ever build a nuclear plant ever again. Gas, wind and solar are all so much cheaper now. And yes, even considering back ups for when the wind is not blowing, wind is much much cheaper than nuclear.
So the obvious solution is just not to build nuclear. Even if you do not consider the real risk to human life, it is a an incredibly expensive extravagance. If you do consider the risk to human life it is absolute madness.
- giantg2 6y agoYou are right about wind and solar being able to bid the lowest rate to the grid. Newer reactor designs such as FAST reactors do not pose a threat to human safety.
- orthecreedence 6y ago> Gas, wind and solar are all so much cheaper now. But cannot power our collective needs (especially industrial), unlike nuclear, which can (at least temporarily). > an incredibly expensive extravagance So is entire cities disappearing under growing oceans because nuclear makes us feel bad. And if we want nuclear to be cheaper, then we should collectively raise the cost of fossil fuels until gas is $20/gallon. Then we'll see how expensive nuclear is.