3 ms·
> a car has a software / OS that is locked down For as long as cars (and other motor vehicles) existed people have been able to work on them including on safet
by Nextgrid 6y ago
> a car has a software / OS that is locked down
For as long as cars (and other motor vehicles) existed people have been able to work on them including on safety systems such as brakes, and the lack of widespread accidents because of this doesn't support the idea of locking them down now.
- jedberg 6y agoPeople make this argument a lot, but the main counterpoint is that if you sell faulty brakes, it's hard for someone externally to exploit that on a massive scale. If you sell faulty car software, it's easy for someone to exploit that remotely on a massive scale.
- ryukafalz 6y agoHow exactly does blocking car owners from working on their cars stop someone from exploiting them on a massive scale?
- noitpmeder 6y agoI mean if I sell faulty brakes, that could be easily disabled by someone doing something to them physically, it is still pretty hard to disable -everyone's- breaks. I have to go and physically, car by car, break them. With sofware, it is as simple as pushing a faulty OTA update. A large portion of all the cars will _instantly_ be impacted.
- beagle3 6y agoAnd yet, that does not answer the question "How exactly does blocking car owners from working on their cars stop someone from exploiting them on a massive scale?" If the OTA is buggy, it can be exploited on a massive scale regardless. If you have a hardware switch that needs to be pressed while updating software, there is no possibility for massive scale exploit.