4 ms·
> But I think "don't use version 1.0" advice applies here just like it does for software. No it doesn’t, because vaccine development is more like bridge buildi
by rayiner 6y ago
> But I think "don't use version 1.0" advice applies here just like it does for software.
No it doesn’t, because vaccine development is more like bridge building than software development.
- Kye 6y agoCan you pull out the threads on that argument a little? Taken at face value, it's not meaningful. Bridges launch with huge, sometimes catastrophic problems.
- unnouinceput 6y agoAnd that's exactly the point. Once it launches it either crashed down or stays up. As for this vaccine it got 30k tests. It's the equivalent of before launching said bridge the entire heavy machinery of the construction company stood on it and didn't collapsed.
- tosseuthansia 6y agoThats quite wrong. Bridges with serious design flaws can stay standing for quite some time and then collapse. Any civil engineering structure can. I mean, the tower of Pisa is a great example. Serious design flaw: building a structure on a flawed foundation (technically the soil is the problem). The structure stands for centuries, but the inevitability of its collapse is certain until the Italians righted it and strengthened the base.
- brobdingnagians 6y agoThe Italian bridge that collapsed after decades because of faulty assumptions about the concrete involved is a more accurate comparison. Assuming we know more than we do, and thinking it has no serious side effects because non have appeared in the first few months is not logically consistent.
- mindcrime 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tacoma_Narrows_Bridge_(1940) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tacoma_Narrows_Bridge_(1940) It was fine... until it wasn't (four months later). Anyway, this analogy is silly. Neither software nor bridges is exactly like the human body and the myriad of complex interactions that happen within. At the end of the day, all I'm saying is that A. under normal circumstances, it takes a lot of time to get a vaccine tested and approved - for good reason. And B. these are not ordinary circumstances, there may be reason to think the process was rushed, and it may be prudent to not rush to be among the first to take the vaccine. And just in case anybody misunderstands what I'm saying, let me reiterate as clearly as I can: This is NOT an anti-vax screed, or an appeal to any conspiracy theories, or anything of that nature. And I am NOT suggesting anyone refuse to get vaccinated in the long-term. I am only suggesting a certain measure of patience, which is probably going to be part of the process anyway due to the logistics of distributing the vaccine.
- floatingatoll 6y agoYou’re suggesting that people prioritize decisions based on individual uncertainty over decisions based on public good. That the logistics of distribution will result in the same outcome as your suggestion does not mitigate the perceived selfishness of your suggestion.
- leetcrew 6y ago> You’re suggesting that people prioritize decisions based on individual uncertainty over decisions based on public good. this is a simplistic and somewhat naive take. the decision to approve and distribute a covid vaccine is not going to be based solely on "public good". a vaccine has immense economic and political significance. it's not unreasonable to wonder how that might affect the approval process.
- mindcrime 6y agoThat the logistics of distribution will result in the same outcome as your suggestion does not mitigate the perceived selfishness of your suggestion. I could not care less about anyone's opinion of my "perceived selfishness".