22 ms·
Well an easy way to know this makes no sense is that if you scaled up Bitcoin power consumption to visas current transaction volume it would require more power
by arcticbull 6y ago
Well an easy way to know this makes no sense is that if you scaled up Bitcoin power consumption to visas current transaction volume it would require more power than the entire world produces and generate more e-waste than the entire world put together. Then multiplied a few times in both cases.
- 0xy 6y agoIncreasing the block size does not require a linear increase in mining capacity so this is incorrect.
- arcticbull 6y agoGreat so let’s just dial it up! Easy! When does it take effect? Right yeah, it doesn’t, and it won’t for all the same reasons it hasn’t yet. Including ideological zealotry about how you should be able to download the entire blockchain onto a USB drive. Among many other reasons.
- 0xy 6y agoIf it won't take effect then your energy analogy is absurdism. You can't hold opposite views.
- arcticbull 6y agoYou misunderstood when I asked "when does it take effect" I meant when will they go ahead and make that change, then followed up with the assertion that they will not ever make that change and therefore this feature isn't particularly relevant.
- rglullis 6y agoNo need to do any of that if people adopt a Layer-2 solution like Lightning. Also, no one is happy about the energy consumption and the centralization of miners in China and subsidized dirty plants, which makes an eventual change to a Proof-of-Stake protocol likely as it matures. When we get to that point, are you going to start using crypto or are you just going to find another reason to bash it?
- arcticbull 6y agoLightning is vaporware, it’s been coming for 5 years, it’s not coming. A layer 2 network does not require Bitcoin you can tie any asset to it. Gold works just fine. Bitcoin is actively user hostile, has a worse wealth distribution than any banana republic, the majority of it is in the control of criminals and shady actors, no I don’t want them to be the wealthiest people on earth while the rest of us fight for scraps. Currencies benefit from their ability to respond to shock, and to the addition of new market actors. Deflation only serves to entrench existing wealth. There’s literally nothing to like about crypto. Nothing. People deserve better than what you’re shilling.
- rglullis 6y ago> the majority of it is in the control of criminals and shady actors, Crime, corruption and fight for power exists independently of what people use for currency. "Criminals and shady actors" also control significant amounts of paper money yet you are not here trying to argue against people to use paper money, right? > I don’t want them to be the wealthiest people on earth while the rest of us fight for scraps. Are you living in North America or the Euro zone? Then you are already top dog, dude. > Deflation only serves to entrench existing wealth Do the existing inflationary policies are helping out in reducing inequality? Who were the greatest beneficiaries of these recent stimulus packages, QE, etc? > There’s literally nothing to like about crypto. I'm pretty sure there are, you just don't want to acknowledge it. But most importantly, the question that I pose to every perennial-crypto-critic: Do you think that the status quo is the best that we can do? If yes, have you stopped to look at all the existing issues with the global financial system and can you honestly make a case that they are all insurmountable problems? If no, do you accept that we need to have people experimenting with alternatives?
- arcticbull 6y agoThe wealthiest people in crypto are all criminals down to satoshi who is likely Paul Le Roux. “If you’re living in North America or the euro zone you’re probably top dog” What? I’m saying that the overwhelming majority of Bitcoin is owned by a small cluster of criminals and everyone else has to fight for scraps of the chain. Those people aren’t who should be wealthy in the new world order. That’s not better than the existing system, it’s worse, and we deserve better. “Do existing financial policies help reduce inequality” It requires a combination of fiscal and monetary policy but I do know that moving to deflationary strictly makes the problem worse by rewarding people who sit on money and don’t move it. I reiterate there’s nothing to like about crypto. It’s all hot garbage. Is the existing system better? 100 times yes. Is the existing system perfect? Lord no. But I don’t think we should replace it with something strictly worse for the sake of a change. We all saw how 2016 played out. I’m in no rush to 2016 our money.