9 ms·
For Alaska shipwreck survivor, losing everything has been ‘sort of liberating’
- ggm 6y ago"The shipping news" brought to life. One lucky man, EPIRB battery done saved him.
- sulam 6y agoI think he had a pretty decent chance either way honestly. He was in a survival suit, out of the water, and managed to go for 3 hours without ending up in the drink. Add the fact that it isn't open ocean, I think he's a pretty resourceful dude.
- blonde_ocean 6y ago> Brodersen, the survivor, was fortunate to get to Ketchikan’s PeaceHealth Medical Center when he did. He’d had a heart attack, and was suffering from hypothermia and cold-induced rhabdomyolysis — a kind of muscle death. Disagree. This is near-death for anyone, especially a 70-year-old.
- sulam 6y agoYeah, his health condition wasn’t great, and the epilepsy is an added element. However, watch the video and it seems like he’s pretty active, not on the brink of death.
- keyle 6y agoBeautiful story, although not sure what he was doing at sea in such conditions. The take away for me is that discovering the goodness in people's heart when you've lost everything is worth more than all our junk.
- japhyr 6y agoThe article said the area he normally anchors in was expected to get rough, so he headed for what should have been a more protected area. He was anchored in that area, and his boat didn't right itself in the wind like it always had before. When things go bad on a boat, they go bad fast. The skiff he planned to hop in and get to shore sank before he could get into it. He did get his survival suit on, which kept him alive long enough to be rescued. This is a 70 year old man who's spent his life fishing in the area. This was his day where almost everything went wrong. But he'd done enough right on his boat, and in his training, to set himself up for rescue. I live in Sitka, where the helicopter crew that did this rescue is based. We hear stories about these kinds of rescues all the time. People have deep respect for USCG personnel here.
- levinb 6y agoAs a former Coastie I appreciate you saying this. Oftentimes, we find government resources wasted for little value. Many a life, however, from pollution, man’s violence, or the intemperance of the sea, has been saved by the Coast Guard. An overlooked service I feel, nearly two decades since I left.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- japhyr 6y agoI've been a volunteer on our local mountain rescue team for almost 20 years, and a couple times a year I get to fly with a USCG helo crew to help people in the mountains. It is such a privilege as a civilian to get to fly with USCG crews; working with them has been one of the highlights of my life. Thank you for your service, and your colleagues' as well. I agree, most people have no idea how hard USCG personnel train, and what goes on when they head out to conduct rescues.
- el_benhameen 6y agoI’ve gone out surfing in conditions too big or rough for my skill level a few times. This was in daylight, in San Diego-warm water, in maybe 8 or 9-foot waves, within sight of the shore, and seeing the waves about to break on my head still scared the living shit out of me. I can’t imagine going out in conditions like the ones in the article. I have lots of respect for the Coast Guard folks who go out into that stuff to help others.
- mypalmike 6y ago"The Coast Guard says there’s no trace of the Irony."
- make_clean 6y agoI see what you did there. I wonder if the article's author intended the same.
- kubanczyk 6y agoIt's such an obvious pun, especially without the italics or quotes, it would be really hard to miss it while you're writing the text yourself! It would be such a waste if the author appended the horrible "(pun intended)".
- cab404 6y ago"For Southeast Alaska shipwreck survivor, losing irony has been ‘sort of liberating’"
- throwawaynov20 6y agousing throwaway for this. >The problem that I’m having is, I don’t know, I don’t exactly have a goal for the rest of my life I can attest to this. I grew up in a very middle class family in a third world country and had been chasing my dreams - become a successful entrepreneur in silicon valley. I worked insanely hard for this, compromising on personal relationships, health, everything. And then, one day, I become successful. Very, very successful. I am quite wealthy now and the wealth will last generations. I am well known in the industry I work in. But it had been a struggle after I achieved success. I found myself depressed. And just last month I was put on medications. Turns out, this is very common problem when you had been chasing your dreams all your life. Like climbing a mountain. Once you have climbed to the top, that's it. You enjoy it for a while and then you start thinking ..now what?
- simonebrunozzi 6y agoSorry to hear this. I am partially in your situation (just much less successful and wealthy, but enough to be relaxed about my career and money), and I am doing quite well, despite this weird covid year. Have you tried to speak with friends, assuming you have a few? Your depression / anxiety is exactly what good friends are for. If I can be of any help, drop me a note ($HNusername at gmail), and stay anonymous if you'd like. I'd be happy to chat with you. Strangers have helped me in my life; I don't mind reciprocating.
- chordalkeyboard 6y agoyou can undergo a process of self-discovery and become a mentor to the people around you. and work on building back some of what you sacrificed to get here. Congratulations!
- throwawaynov20 6y agoI am doing that and have been donating both time and money to various causes but it is not something that brings me inherent joy. I am just living each day as it comes, but this is nowhere close to the fanatic/adrenaline filled goal driven days I have lived. moreover, I don't even indulge in anything expensive, so I don't even feel motivated to earn more money or spend it.
- CalChris 6y agoMy one and hopefully only experience with anything like this was as part of a delivery crew going from San Francisco to Santa Barbara. Racers, we left in a gale but we were going downwind and it was easy living. The skipper had bought a $100 genoa which eventually fully delaminated and shredded. It was blowing 30+ which didn't seem that bad since, again, we were going downwind. But we needed to gybe to stay on course. Gybing was not going to be fun but I suggested that we just chicken gybe, a dinghy school maneuver, to make life just a little safer. We did and got it over with. Still 30-40 knots had us racing down the coast and Point Conception was in our future. Translate Point Conception from Spanish to English and you get the idea. So we decided to radio in to Morro Bay. Channel 16 had been broadcasting Morro Bay is closed. Do not approach Morro Bay. That includes you. In fact, Morro Bay did not even pick up but eventually Long Beach did. They said Morro Bay would radio back which they did. Morro Bay was very professional. How many souls on board? Are you wearing life jackets? What is your sailing experience? Have you been in to Morro Bay before? ... A note about Morro Bay. In normal conditions, it's easy peasy. But in a blow, the waves are rolling south directly into the breakwater, the rocks. You cannot go in normally. They sent two cutters out. One was put in front of us and one behind us. We surfed down the waves. They timed it and said that when the boat in front turns left, you turn left. We did. After that, motored up the channel, tied up at the YC and went to sleep. Pancakes the next day in Morro Bay and then Point Conception (I've been turned back by Point Conception going north several times) was easy + beautiful. The Coasties? They do this every day.
- UncleOxidant 6y ago> The skipper had bought a $100 genoa What is a genoa in this context?
- erik_seaberg 6y agoAn oversized foresail that isn't a great idea in high wind. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genoa_(sail) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genoa_(sail)
- CalChris 6y ago
- chrissnell 6y agoEPIRBs are incredibly handy devices in an emergency. Unlike SPOT trackers and such, the response is managed and coordinated by the US military. If your EPIRB signal makes it out, someone will come looking for you. They work on dry land, too. Very useful to have if you like to do trips to the desert backcountry. I ended up purchasing a satellite phone after ditching my SPOT tracker but if I had to do it over, I'd just buy the EPIRB. The marine versions activate automatically when dropped in the water. Typically, on a sailboat, you would lash it somewhere on deck where it would pop up to the surface and activate if the boat sinks. The outside of a life raft shell is one such spot.
- tialaramex 6y ago> the response is managed and coordinated by the US military. Who is responsible will vary around the world. If you're at sea it will likely be some sort of coast guard or possibly even a navy, but on land it's often a civilian agency charged with rescuing people who've got into trouble far from civilisation or even handed off to volunteers. COSPAS/SARSAT (the satellite technology that makes these beacons work) is a rare example of Cold War co-operation on technology for peaceful ends. Hence why SARSAT makes obvious sense in English (Seach And Rescue SATellite) while COSPAS is Russian. Before all this starts, there are analogue radio beacons. Those are pretty dumb, you can still find them in some personal planes flown by pilots too cheap to upgrade - they just play a siren tone on a fixed reserved frequency when triggered. If somebody is tuned to the reserved frequency and close enough, they can hear your beacon, with some pretty easy technology a group can triangulate and find the emergency. Might save your life, if people are searching and if you can survive maybe a day or two while they look. COSPAS/SARSAT says wait, we have satellites, put a radio "mirror" on a satellite at that frequency, and now we don't have to search any more. We sit at the ground station for the satellite, we hear distress beacon sirens from existing beacons on the ground, we can use mathematics to work out based on where the satellite is and the Doppler effect where the radio beacon is in a few minutes. That works up to a point, but there sure is a lot of other junk that's broadcasting (intentionally or not) on the reserved frequency, and you've got no idea when your rescue helicopter scrambles are you going to find: A small plane with no filed fight plan and six badly injured people? One lone hiker who is just lost in the hills? A pile of garbage somebody threw out which happens to include a radio beacon with just barely working batteries? Could be anything. Almost always it was nothing. That's expensive and bad for morale. So, modern COSPAS/SARSAT beacons are digital, and the satellites are now smarter. The beacon has a unique identifier and if fitted with or connected to a suitable receiver (very common on boats and somewhat common elsewhere) it can transmit its GPS co-ordinates. This means now the base station isn't trying to guess if this is a beacon with a low battery or a garage door opener, they know instantly it's beacon #4843931 and it says it's fourteen miles off the north coast of Scotland. This cut false alarms by an order of magnitude at least, and reduced search time to almost zero. False alarms are still the majority of all alerts though - emergencies don't happen that often and humans are lazy and incompetent leading to false alarms. The current work on COSPAS/SARSAT is return link. Right now you trigger the beacon and then... maybe you get rescued. But that's not great emotionally and we know in some emergencies hope is key to survival. Is anybody coming? If you're clinging to the wreck of a yacht ten minutes can seem like an hour, surely the beacon you triggered just isn't working? So return link is a mechanism by which GPS messages are used to tell your beacon "Received. Rescue coming" and perhaps some day more complicated messaging like "Cannot Land. Ground team on its way to you. Stay here".
- thomasfl 6y agoImagine losing all your stuff in an accident. Then imagine all the strain the production of all that stuff had on the environment. When you are dry, warm and have a few high quality pieces of clothing, you are pretty much set. Add some seriouscrelationships and some good friends, and you are probably not to unhappy. This survivor in Alaska lost a floating home, but got some new friends and a new life.
- kubanczyk 6y agoIt's been a recurring theme here on HN, but yeah he'd be unhappy. One thing missing from the checklist is the social status and all the elaborate signaling that goes with it. The "good friends" and especially "relationships" might never materialize or sustain themselves without the status. Less social people often overlook that part, I know that I do.
- rainbowzootsuit 6y ago"Only after disaster can we be resurrected. It's only after you've lost everything that you're free to do anything. Nothing is static, everything is evolving, everything is falling apart." — Tyler Durden in Fight Club
- ycombonator 6y agoUS Coast Guard: balls of steel
- _wldu 6y agoAn older man once told me that, "sometimes things own you". I didn't understand at the time (I was younger), but now I know exactly what he meant.
- rufus_foreman 6y agoYou're not supposed to talk about that.
- tomohawk 6y agoPhysically saved by the EPIRB and Coast Guard, spiritually saved by his great attitude and perspective.