4 ms·
Not sure I understand - in your example, isn’t it the archiving that’s to blame, rather than the tree/threaded format? In more traditional forums (e.g. VBB) on
by mft_ 6y ago
Not sure I understand - in your example, isn’t it the archiving that’s to blame, rather than the tree/threaded format?
In more traditional forums (e.g. VBB) one effectively replicates the tree format through quoting - just without the tree being so clearly displayed.
- Sharlin 6y agoIn tree-format discussion, new replies disappear into the depths of subtrees, whereas in a linear thread they're always at the bottom and easily marked as new. There should be a way to somehow switch between the formats.
- mft_ 6y agoFair point - thanks.
- jlokier 6y agoSome forums do both at the same time, which can be nice. E.g. showing every comment linearly with time, but each comment that has replies also has a "show replies" link which expands when clicked to show the replies as children. Those replies are the same comments shown later in the linear list; it's just a convenient alternate way of showing them on request in context.