2 ms·
This sounds good superficially but I don't think it actually makes sense. People can and should have higher expectations for investments than lottery tickets.
by loeg 6y ago
This sounds good superficially but I don't think it actually makes sense. People can and should have higher expectations for investments than lottery tickets. And primary-residence mortgages are relatively safe and liquid compared with private investments. I.e., these things are of a different kind entirely than private investment.
The real question to me is, what is a "private" investment if everyone can invest in it? Why isn't it subject to the same reporting requirements as a "public" investment?
- nixonpjoshua1 6y agoI think to allow small business and startups to flourish. It is important to not subject all companies to the reporting requirements of public companies, smaller organizations just don't have the spare resources and it really would hurt them being nimble and getting established. This of course means that any investor into such a company needs to have a more intimate relationship and understanding of the company despite the lack of detailed reporting, which is at least one reason to have accredited investor rules.
- gojomo 6y agoSo, there can be a wealth test - but no competence test! – for investments that might be positive expectation? But then absolutely no limits to who and how much someone can spend on rigged games of chance with guaranteed negative-expectation. How does that make sense? You're right, the 'public'/'private' distinction is confusing and outdated. It should just be 'high-reporting' (certified by accountants/lawyers/exchanges to meet certain standards) and 'low-reporting'. Perhaps tax-advantaged retirement accounts shouldn't be allowed into 'low-reporting' situations. But with a person's own excess money, they shouldn't face a wealth test to invest it anywhere their judgement guides them - if they're allowed to gamble, donate, burn, over-leverage, etc that money a thousand other ways to zero as well.