3 ms·
From what I understand, the warehouse was a collection of confiscated goods by customs at the port. So I can easily see that the managers at the warehouse didn'
by jcranmer 6y ago
From what I understand, the warehouse was a collection of confiscated goods by customs at the port. So I can easily see that the managers at the warehouse didn't know and didn't care about proper safety storage procedures for these hazardous goods, since they hadn't been planning to acquire them in the first place. (In US legal terms, this would be recklessness).
However, evidently some people (their affiliation is not clear to me) were aware of the major risks this caused and pleaded with the judiciary to do something about it, to no avail. I'm somewhat mystified as to who exactly it is that recklessly put the ammonium nitrate where it is, and I think that the desire to avoid blame here is strong enough (and the blame itself widespread enough) that a proper investigation will only end in stonewalling or scapegoating.
- lotsofpulp 6y ago>I'm somewhat mystified as to who exactly it is that recklessly put the ammonium nitrate where it is Some underpaid and undereducated laborers. Unfortunately, this society did not have sufficiently developed governance to force the proper storage of ammonium nitrate. There were multiple warnings issued over the years, and multiple mandates by the judicial system, but the political will to spend the money to move it did not exist, so it did not get moved.
- bigbubba 6y agoHow much money would it really have cost? Worse case they conscript a dozen guys with plastic snow shovels to dump it onto the water. That would be very far from ideal, but a hell of a lot better than half the city blowing up. If they paid a dozen guys double the minimum wage for Lebanon and it took a whole month, that would be about $10,000.
- kqr 6y agoThey were probably not deciding between moving the AN or twiddling their thumbs. They were likely faced with a thousand other prospective things to do, many of which seemed more important than the AN. After all, the AN had been lying there without blowing up for years, so surely someone else is keeping tabs on that too. ---- What I'm saying is that it's easy in hindsight to see how stupid a decision was, but to the actors at the time they were facing a much more complicated situation with less obvious tradeoffs. Until we accept this, we will only have finger-pointing blame assigned and accidents will keep happening, because we'll just install new humans in the same flawed system that created the accident.
- Already__Taken 6y agoWere you work has tons of explosives currently on fire and... you call the fire brigade and film? I seriously doubt just how many if anyone actually at the port day to day knew it was there.
- snypher 6y agoPersonally I'd rather destroy half the city instead of dumping 3000 tons of nitrates into the waterways. There's proper ways to do things and they don't have to very expensive.
- agapon 6y agoMy takeaway: some stuff is better not to confiscate / store as evidence. No one would store a jar of milk in a warehouse. No one would store piles of TNT or dynamite in such conditions. But they were storing just "goods". Lacking understanding of what those goods are and how they must be stored.
- rtkwe 6y agoThere were several reports over the years that warned them of how dangerous the AN was it was ignored because it was easier to ignore than to force someone to accept it for disposal.
- smsm42 6y agoTBH it is a really sucky problem to solve... As I understand the goods got there from some shipping company that in the meantime went bankrupt. The port authorities weren't able to just make 2KT of ammonium nitrate disappear - and probably were legally not allowed to anyway. There really was nobody who was responsible for it and no procedure for getting rid of it - it's not like you can just throw it to the garbage... It's a classic bureaucratic situation where nobody can or is willing to take responsibility, and if it wasn't explosive, these sacks probably could be in there for decades...
- iSnow 6y agoApocryphal, but I read they tried to get the military to transport the stuff away but the explosion came before anyone decided. It's the usual mix of carelessness, lack of security guidelines, bureaucratic inertia and corruption. How hard would it really have been to rent a warehouse outside the city to store explosive and flammable material at?