2 ms·
>Its view is supported by Bjorn Fehrm, an aeronautical analyst at consultants Leeham News. “The aircraft is perfectly flyable without the MCAS software,” he say
by salawat 6y ago
>Its view is supported by Bjorn Fehrm, an aeronautical analyst at consultants Leeham News. “The aircraft is perfectly flyable without the MCAS software,” he says - pointing out that the system is not actually meant to deploy during normal flight.
That is some high quality equivocation.
There was never any question the MAX could fly without MCAS. The important question is: is it certifiable for Civil Transport duties without MCAS?
The answer to that question, is no. The FAA themselves said as much.
Unfortunately, I'll need to run back through my stack of MAX related literature to find it again to properly cite later, but I'm fairly certain it should be found in Final*, Executive Summary, high level description of the control system/Conclusions...
I can bloody see the line seared into my forebrain, not that that means much. It'll be out of the edit window, but I'll come back with a cite unless someone else has the time and interest to do the digging before I get back to it.
- salawat 6y ago>https://www.faa.gov/news/media/attachments/737-MAX-RTS-Preliminary-Summary-v-1.pdf https://www.faa.gov/news/media/attachments/737-MAX-RTS-Preli... There we are. Page 10, paragraph 3. So if you take this Bjarn at his word, he is correct. The plane is flyable without MCAS, but would be ineligible for certification to serve in a capacity as a Civil Air Transport. I'm sorry, but I really hope people are not lulled or otherwise duped by the mere passing of time that this thing is fine. I accept that pilots can now safely fly it. I also accept it is safer now than it was before. I will not ever accept that it was a design that was arrived at in good faith, and no matter what flowery accolades are heaped on it by regulators, it will remain irrevocably tainted in my eyes. A monument to greed over integrity, to a complete failure and subversion of the celebrated "Process" credited with unquestionably rendering air travel safer over the last century, by the forces of a cultural rot fueled by the financialization of a great firm as naught but a mechanism fpr economic growth and value extraction first, rather than as an entity first and foremost dedicated to the production of safe, reliable, and revolutionary aircraft. I refuse the MAX mot because there it has not been fixed or rendered safe, but because I refuse to award the it's maker for their betrayal of their obligation to the flying public, regardless of how successful their legal did at convincing their regulator that they operated in good faith. There is too damn much reek of bad faith for me to acknowledge the lack of judicial declaration of bad faith as anything exculpatory. Call me vindictive, a fool, overly idealistic, call me what you will, but that doesn't happen without a lot of rotten slime to grease the gears of calamity.