3 ms·
“ You would be right to say that Intel couldn’t make the M1. It’s not because Intel’s fabs are struggling or Apple has found tricks no one else in the world kno
by zepto 6y ago
“ You would be right to say that Intel couldn’t make the M1. It’s not because Intel’s fabs are struggling or Apple has found tricks no one else in the world knows about. It’s because Apple controls the entire software stack and therefore knows what they need on the chip. Intel caters to the entire market (one the M1 just noticeably shrunk) with myriad integrators, workloads, and users, and each has different concerns and priorities making accelerated algorithm blocks useless to some and not-fast-enough for others.”
This is an important point. It applies up and down the stack for everything Apple does.
The people who suggest breaking up Apple are correct that it would destroy them, by forcing them to use inefficient generic components at every level.
If we want competition against Apple, the way to get there is not by hobbling them with the inefficiency of the old paradigm.
It’s by the rest of the industry figuring out how to collaborate on delivering similar gains without vertical integration.
- alwillis 6y agoIt’s by the rest of the industry figuring out how to collaborate on delivering similar gains without vertical integration. This is one of the smartest things I've seen on HN in a long time. This is exactly what has to happen if the other companies don't want Apple to eat their lunch.
- singhrac 6y agoThe thing is... doesn't Samsung already do this with their Exynos chips? And even with Qualcomm, they must already build them with Android (even a particular phone) in mind, right? Yet somehow the A14 is faster than a Snapdragon 865. I think strategically if Exynos put pressure on Qualcomm in a nontrivial way (e.g. Samsung switched entirely, and started selling Exynos chips to their competitors) that would change the game. Maybe the fab needs to be spun out of Samsung, just as Intel's fabs might be spun out as well.
- zepto 6y agoI don’t see Samsung doing this. It’s one thing knowing that you are going to run Android. It’s entirely another to decide to be able to invest years in optimizing reference counting in collaboration with the compiler team committing to ARC.
- ksec 6y agoSamsung and Qualcomm have different priorities. Vendors are already complaining to Qualcomm about expensive packages due to 5G. They want it cheaper, at the same time people are suggesting Qualcomm's CPU goes faster. You can only have one of them.
- saurik 6y agoThe places where people want Apple broken up are generally places where we all know it will make the result "worse" but will enable interoperability and competition and break down lock-in and empower users and lead to more repairable and less wasteful devices and (and and)... the idea is that what is best for an entire market isn't merely "the fastest thinnest devices with the longest battery life and the most integrated stacks" if that implies buying into one of a handful of locked down systems, but instead that we should actively enforce an optimization that is harmful for all of those companies and potentially their products but which causes an ecosystem of interoperable components where users have commensurate power to make demands back on platforms. It is the very true fact that economies of scale and efficiencies of vertical integration exist that make regulation and anti-trust law so critically important to prevent the world from being made up of an oligopoly of maybe three giant companies that each make one of everything you might ever own, all beautifully integrated with their own products while being almost entirely incompatible with the products made by the other two, with cross promotions from tying and forced purchases from bundling all making it difficult-to-impossible for a new company to independently introduce anything new without replicating the entire vertical stack of an incumbent.
- zepto 6y agoWith all due respect, I don’t see any logic explaining how an ecosystem of interoperable products where users have commensurafe power to make demands back on platforms would be a consequence of breaking up Apple. I do think it’s a positive situation to wish, but the idea that it would arise simply as a result of breaking up Apple needs some serious explanation. Repairability leading to less waste is also a seems like an unlikely consequence of making devices less integrated. Apple’s device lifetimes are much greater than any of their competitors. I personally strongly value software freedom, and do not think we can afford to let the current situation persist for all time, but it pains me to see things like right to repair be tied in with the problems of the software ecology. One seems like Luddism, and the other seems like a bedrock of a sane digital future, two things that don’t mix well. One step which would seem to serve both of these goals, would be to require all devices that fit some general category of ‘general purpose computer’ to permit alternative operating systems to be installed. But that has absolutely zero to do with breaking up Apple. If we need rights, let’s actually say what they are. Breaking companies up doesn’t create rights. The null hypothesis for what would happen if you break up Apple is that Android would simply dominate, with no improvements over its current locked down state, which is admittedly slightly more free than Apple, but in no way resembles the utopia you describe. We’d probably get Facebook and Amazon forks of Android gaining more traction this time around, but offering none of what you and I want in terms of freedom.
- freehunter 6y ago>The people who suggest breaking up Apple are correct that it would destroy them I haven't actually heard too many people calling for Apple to be broken up (most of what I hear is around increased regulation) but when I do hear breakups being talked about, it's more along the line of removing their value-adds like TV+ and Music+ and App Store. Those are the things where you could make an argument that they're hurting competition, not the coupling of their OS and CPU.
- zepto 6y agoA lot of people, including a recent US presidential candidate, are suggesting a breakup - see Saurik’s comment.