4 ms·
Edit: I just talked to YouTube support directly and yep it's exactly what I anticipated below. It only affects channels not yet in the YPP. Larger channels who
by nickjj 6y ago
Edit: I just talked to YouTube support directly and yep it's exactly what I anticipated below. It only affects channels not yet in the YPP. Larger channels who are in the YPP but explicitly choose not to monetize videos will not get these new ads placed into their videos. At least not with this TOS change.
Original comment:
The wording of this isn't 100% crystal clear but I have a feeling this article might be making this out to be way worse than it is.
I have 10k subs on YouTube and made a decision not to run ads on my channel from the beginning because I care more about the viewing experience than profiting.
Technically I'm in the YouTube Partner Program and I choose not to turn on monetization for my videos. Monetization is basically a checkbox you can turn on and off for each video and then if you enable it, you choose some information about how the ads are shown.
Going by the TOS update's wording, it sounds like if you're in the YPP then your videos will have not have these new ads placed in them if you choose to disable monetization for a video.
It sounds like it's only going to affect channels who have a handful of subs and views, in which case you were making $0 guaranteed anyways because you couldn't turn monetization on due to not being in the YPP. The only difference now is YouTube will make some money off your views which seems reasonable since they are hosting it for free, and realistically it'll be pennies at best if you have a small channel with 15 views per video.
- mdoms 6y ago"It's not as bad as it seems because it doesn't affect me personally". Thanks for your input mate.
- nickjj 6y ago> "It's not as bad as it seems because it doesn't affect me personally". Thanks for your input mate. I didn't say that, so you might want to remove your quotes. The article made it seem like people with 5 million daily views who decided not to monetize their videos would get ads placed into their videos and make $0 with no way to opt-out while YouTube profited from ads in those views. That would be way different (and worse) than what's really happening.
- ArunRaja 6y agoGood points! My analysis: 1. "Youtube partner program" can be terminated after 6 months of zero interaction with users, though creator shall reapply. 2. Youtube shall run ads on non YPP videos. So idea seems to be, takeaway 'ideal creators' money from them to 'Youtube'. Is it fair to disassociate creator from "YPP/ads share" for 6 month/more dis-engagement?