4 ms·
Probably doesn’t matter since the war on urls is mostly a myth perpetuated by outrage-bait blogspam. By default (i.e. until you click the bar) only showing the
by Spivak 6y ago
Probably doesn’t matter since the war on urls is mostly a myth perpetuated by outrage-bait blogspam.
By default (i.e. until you click the bar) only showing the part of the URL that the site doesn’t control is really good for security and avoiding phishing. Now apple.paypal.secure.wendys.scamsite.info/payus/wwwcitibank just shows scamsite.info. This is a good thing! And doubly because URL paths and fragments have been made largely irrelevant to end users as app routes.
If you're going to rant about the death of the URL you should complain to HN as well that only shows the domain next to posts.
- zbrozek 6y agoWhy not just bold that part and leave the rest?
- Spivak 6y agoIf we're at the point where we're de-emphasizing something because it's almost always visual noise and you don't need to see it often why is "hide it until the bar is selected" worse?
- zbrozek 6y agoI work at an Alphabet company, so at work I use Chrome. Lots of internal tools are really buggy on anything but Chrome, so I have little choice. There's lots of copy-paste of URLs, including fragments, and it's really jarring to have the text suddenly change right after a mouse-up. It's surprising and unpleasant. And of course the browser tries to modify the selection between mouse-up and copy to make sure I get the whole thing, so now the software is not doing what I told it to. It seems harmless to show the full URL and not bait-and-switch the text upon interaction. I don't see it as the browser's job to protect users from their incompetence.
- themacguffinman 6y agoChrome already visually de-emphasizes the URL path, clearly they don't think it's enough. If you care at all about the health of the web, you should support browsers in protecting users from their own incompetence. Users don't blame themselves for phishing & fraud, when it runs rampant on a platform they simply switch and the end result is that native walled gardens that do protect users win over the web. This is exactly what happened with news on the mobile web; mobile news websites got so slow that Apple & Facebook started gaining a lot of ground with completely closed & proprietary news platforms (Apple News, Facebook Instant), until Google released AMP which both helped & pressured news orgs to get their shit together on the web.
- zbrozek 6y agoYou started with protection and ended with performance, but I don't see where you connect them. Could you clarify? I see these kinds of features sort of like padding on football players. It enables (encourages?) carelessness. Maybe the jury is still out on the net outcome, but I'm so far away from web development and the overall ecosystem as to have no opinion.
- themacguffinman 6y agoThe common theme is that in both cases, the web was losing ground to closed, native platforms. If web browsers don't protect users, they stand to lose users to platforms that do protect users in much the same way that slow websites lost users to Apple News & Facebook Instant. Of course it encourages carelessness, that's what users want: they want to care less about the tech they use.They simply want the benefits of tech, not the maintenance or burden of care. It's why many prefer an iPhone that makes all their software choices for them. It's why many trust an email provider to sort & filter their email instead of doing it themselves.
- wzdd 6y agoThe site controls all parts of the URL. Your example would much more likely show "paypal-accounts.info" or similar.
- Spivak 6y agoTrue but users are way less likely to fall for that then the hack to push 'paypal.com' to the leftmost position in the bar.
- chrisweekly 6y agoYour point about domains and phishing may have some merit. But I strongly object to the idea in your last sentence: >"URL paths and fragments have been made largely irrelevant to end users as app routes" No. Some SPA scenarios, for some end users != "largely irrelevant".
- Spivak 6y agoI mean it's literally one click away. Let me tell you how relevant /reply?id=25150055&goto=threads%3Fid%3DSpivak%2325150055 is to me on this page. If it was id=25151055 I would be worried.