4 ms·
> I mean, once upon a time I believed some variation of what breck is claiming. I don't believe it any longer; I currently tend to believe that at least some co
by kelnos 6y ago
> I mean, once upon a time I believed some variation of what breck is claiming. I don't believe it any longer; I currently tend to believe that at least some copyright law is probably better for society than no copyright law.
I've gone back and forth on this as well, though my opinion has never been as extreme and uncompromising as breck's. I believe copyright law has gotten entirely out of hand, but agree with you that we probably should have some kind of copyright law.
> But they seem to be espousing it consistently.
Which is the problem, I think. It just comes off as naive and foolish, and shows a lack of critical thinking or practical understanding of how the world works and why it works the way it does.
Regarding sympathy: Disney uses copyright to fuel its greed. Foster uses it to make a decent living doing what he loves and believes will delight others. Having no sympathy for Foster in this situation is heartless and cold; I have zero respect for anyone who would take that position. Perhaps the other commenter is going overboard on hyperbole to suggest that breck has no sympathy for "anybody", but a lack of sympathy for Foster in particular says some strongly negative things about breck's character. And there comes that critical thinking again: it is perfectly reasonable -- and desirable, in a healthy society -- to be sympathetic toward Foster while still uncompromisingly believing that IP law is unethical.
- breck 6y agoI do try and look at things critically, but with regards to Imaginary Property laws, I think there is an order of magnitude difference between right and wrong. There is still not enough good critical research on the topic If anyone know of any orgs focused on this doing non-traditional research into IP/or specifically working to abolish them(rules out EFF, which I support but this is not their focus), please let me know. One positive side effect of my "trolling" is getting to read the more eloquent discusssions between people like you and jholman.