3 ms·
I think there are two issues here: 1) breck seems to not understand what the whole thing is actually about. It's about one party with a contractual obligation
by kelnos 6y ago
I think there are two issues here:
1) breck seems to not understand what the whole thing is actually about. It's about one party with a contractual obligation to pay another party some money every time the first party sells a book. Even if copyright law disappeared tomorrow, that contractual obligation would still exist. Sure, it might be harder for Disney to sell those books if copyright didn't exist and people could copy them for free, but that wouldn't remove their royalty obligation, as that's a contractual obligation that does not rely on copyright to function.
2) breck's attitude toward IP law is just... tiresome and annoying, I guess? Most people here likely either don't agree with it, or are sympathetic to it, but believe breck's ideal world is just generally unworkable from a practical perspective. Personally I find that kind of anti-IP thinking to be naive, and people who push it in the way breck is doing just come off as kinda trollish.
breck is of course absolutely right that copyright law -- like all our laws -- is enforced at the point of a gun. But... so what? That's how laws work.
> From this, breck reasons that if ADF has a contract with Disney that, to make any sense at all, requires that copyright be enforced...
Just to call this out specifically: no, that's completely incorrect. Even if there was no copyright law, Disney's contract with Foster would still be in full effect.
But ok, let's admit that contract would have been absurd from day one, because in a no-copyright world, both Disney (well, at that time, George Lucas) and Foster would know that they'd never be able to sell any more than a few copies that would then be freely copied and distributed. So they'd make like $12 and that would be it. So some other arrangement would have been made up front. Perhaps LucasFilm would have made up a contract with Foster that says they would be Foster's patron, and would pay him some monthly or yearly stipend, for some specified number of years, as a reward for writing the book. Or whatever. And then let's say Disney later buys LucasFilm while the contract is still paying out. Disney is still contractually obligated to continue paying, but they decide they don't feel like it, and don't pay.
And this bit is what the original article is about. It has nothing to do with copyright; it's about a giant corporation refusing to honor its contractual obligations when those obligations are to regular people who don't have the resources to fight them. Coming here and dropping a low effort "I have no sympathy" comment is a waste of our time and shows a lack of empathy, justified with an argument (against IP law) that is unrelated to Foster's woes or Disney's obligations.
- breck 6y ago> like all our laws -- is enforced at the point of a gun. But... so what? That's how laws work. that's a fair point. But an extremely critical aspect of contract law is the notion of unenforceable contracts. The court is not going to enforce a contract to share racketeering profits, and it shouldn't enforce Imaginary Property contracts either. > just generally unworkable from a practical perspective. Personally I find that kind of anti-IP thinking to be naive We are moving there (I've been working in this area for nearly 2 decades now—but obviously some people many more decades than hat), but it is a continuous struggle.