9 ms·
>They know they can't do much to stand up against US. I may be wrong but I think Denmark's security is based on US millitary support through NATO. This applies
by coldtea 6y ago
>They know they can't do much to stand up against US. I may be wrong but I think Denmark's security is based on US millitary support through NATO. This applies to most EU countries. Russia is too threatening to upset your security guarantor.
It's amazing how this Cold War old-wives-tale is still what Americans believe...
Russia is not USSR - a superpower with half of Europe under its wings -, and is not a threat to anyone (and in no great shape to be a threat, even if they wanted), except immediate neighbors they have disputes with for centuries, and which, more often than not, are themselves armed and weaponized by NATO as proxies against it.
- elevenoh 6y ago"Russia is not USSR - a superpower with half of Europe under its wings -, and is not a threat to anyone" Haven't we entered an age where 'non-eyeToEye-threats' can do enormous damage, even if by error (e.g. nuclear bombing the US)?
- coldtea 6y agoNo, we're still in the age when a certain superpower messes up the whole world, supports fundamentalists and jihadis, destabilizes regions, invades countries, and then cries about the terrorism threat...
- throwaway4good 6y agoAgreed. France alone probably has sufficient military power to balance Russia. European countries can stand up to what is obviously unacceptable (industrial espionage conducted by US military intelligence). But Denmark in the later years have chosen not to.
- goatinaboat 6y agoFrance alone probably has sufficient military power to balance Russia. It depends on the theatre. At sea, probably, in a nuclear exchange France has sufficient deterrent capability. But in a land war, tank on tank the way God meant it to be, France’s 200 tanks are no match for Russia’s thousands. Remember purchasing power parity. Russia may be poorer than France, but it’s stuff costs a lot less too.
- blackflame7000 6y agoThe A-10 (or equivalent) is highly effective against tanks so it would probably come down to air superiority which the Russians would probably win easily against anyone not (china or US)
- goatinaboat 6y agoThe A-10 (or equivalent) is highly effective against tanks France has no A10s and S500 allows Russia to deny airspace to it anyway.
- jabl 6y agoI don't think you'd be using an S500 against an A-10 in any case..
- nix23 6y ago>tank on tank the way God meant it to be Tanks are not used for that anymore, they are used as little fortresses in cities, but fighting on a open field..well you have seen what happened in the first and second iraq war.
- nl 6y agoYou have this completely backwards. Tanks are deathtraps in cities. Attackers trap them with obstacles and then attack with RPGs. See the footage on YouTube in Chechnya or Syria. In the open battlefield as in Iraq 1 (especially) and 2 they were very effective although of course airpower is the key factor.
- nix23 6y agoModern Tanks have a high resistance against RPG's, you can read for yourself. https://www.armyupress.army.mil/Portals/7/Primer-on-Urban-Operation/Documents/Breaking-the-Mold.pdf https://www.armyupress.army.mil/Portals/7/Primer-on-Urban-Op... >In the open battlefield as in Iraq 1 (especially) and 2 they were very effective That was artillery and aircraft's, mostly NOT Tank VS Tank.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> France alone probably has sufficient military power to balance Russia On its homeland. France has limited excess ability to project power to e.g. Lithuania. Or Greenland. About 10,000 troops abroad to Russia's nearly 50,000. (Though an advantage in carriers.)
- ekabod 6y agocarriers and submarines loaded with nuclear missiles are not enough for you to project power in Greenland?
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> carriers and submarines loaded with nuclear missiles are not enough for you to project power in Greenland? No. Nuclear deterrents work against nuclear threats. But a lot of modern warfare is by proxy. Subnuclear force is what matters. More tangibly: Russia starts constructing a base on Greenland. Does France risk nuclear exchange to challenge it? For that matter, would America? Of course not. Sanctions, blockading the construction site and threatening to build similarly near Russian assets would be the game. Each of these, individually, is within Paris' capacity. (Except, maybe, sanctions.) But collectively, no.
- themihai 6y agoDenmark is not France and Denmark has no guarantee that France would step in to stop a Russian invasion.
- DiogenesKynikos 6y agoWhy on Earth would Russia invade Denmark?
- SilentBan 6y agoIn order to gain a direct way to the Atlantic ocean. They can currently reach it trough the Arctic Ocean and Black Sea -> Mediterranean Sea. But direct way will be nice. Another reason would be to insert themselves between Scandinavia and Germany.
- loopback_device 6y agoKaliningrad Oblast is right between Scandinavia and Germany already, and Russia also has plenty of mainland coastline in the Baltic Sea.
- themihai 6y agoBecause (if) it can. You know there was a time when Russia/SU annexed Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania, right?
- DiogenesKynikos 6y agoRussia isn't the Soviet Union, and Denmark isn't in the Baltic.
- virgilp 6y agoWhy on Earth would Russia invade Ukraine?
- hestefisk 6y ago
- bobthepanda 6y agoDoes it? France and the UK started the Libya conflict but had to call in the US via NATO for help.
- coldtea 6y ago"Had to call in the US" -> "the US wanted its cut as top dog, and invited itself"
- bobthepanda 6y agoSarkozy and Cameron publicly pushing Clinton and Obama to join in on enforcement for weeks would indicate something else, given the marked policy difference between how that was handled and Syria. Libya is not really something America has a strategic interest in.
- somesortofsystm 6y agoAmerica wasn't going to let Libya establish the African Dinar.
- thefounder 6y agoExactly! If you watch Obama's past interviews he says explictely that US was disappointed by France's weakness on Libya. Not to mention that France made a big deal of its "decisive" action after the US took down the anti-air defense.
- rich_sasha 6y ago> Russia is not USSR - a superpower with half of Europe under its wings -, and is not a threat to anyone Not by choice, Russians still think the collapse of USSR a tragic mistake, and Putin’s rhetoric ties directly back to it. Russian “defence” spending is skyrocketing, Russia is holding frequent manoeuvres righ in NATO borders, keeps flying bombers ever-so-slightly into NATO country airspace’s... and most of all, Russia shows it is more than happy to apply brute force to achieve political goals. In Ukraine, Georgia, who’s next? Denmark, Poland and Sweden, not to mention the Baltic states, are rightly concerned about Russia’s posturing. If it’s not meant to be intimidating and creating a low-level Cold War, then it’s a very odd way of showing neighbourly love. I’m sure comparisons to American imperialism will follow, and maybe justifiably so. But crucially, US does not invade European countries, voila the pertinent difference.
- throwaway56034 6y agoRussian “defence” spending is skyrocketing, This is wrong, it barely keeps up with inflation: https://www.sipri.org/commentary/topical-backgrounder/2020/russias-military-spending-frequently-asked-questions https://www.sipri.org/commentary/topical-backgrounder/2020/r... This is a whopping 9% of the yearly defense spending of the US.
- Jarolis 6y agoThe US is irrelevant for European defense though. They're no longer a reliable partner and nobody seriously believes we can rely on them if anything does happen. So we're down to France and Germany, and I'm not sure Germany's military is particularly competent. The way I see it, Russia is far more efficient at defense spending than most of the EU countries, so they're a legitimate threat even if they "only" match France in spending.
- redflame7 6y agoYea The US's GDP is roughly 13 times that of Russia. It's not even close to the way it was during the Cold War.
- thefounder 6y agoWell Russia already anexed Crimea and is fighting a proxy war in Ukraine. You may not find Ukraine enough European for you to count. Next: other Eastern European countries. Next: the baltic countries.
- blackflame7000 6y agoThey’d still have a long ways to go to even get back what they had as the USSR. Russia isn’t the soviet union but in time they could be or they could be a US Ally someday. Imagine a world where the US and Russia were on great terms... China would be very unhappy with that.
- elmo2you 6y ago> Well Russia already annexed Crimea .. Yet another show of either (willful) ignorance or (intentional) peddling of (Western) propaganda. People may think whatever they want about what happened to Crimea and Eastern Ukraine, but to called that an annexation (or an invasion, as many have) is disingenuous as best. It's no secret (in fact, it's on public record) that it was the USA who pumped copious amounts of money in getting a "favorable" group of very questionable "politicians" in power in Kiev. While presented as "spreading democracy and freedom", in the backdrop Western companies (with strong government ties) were making deals to take control of the natural resources in both Crimea and Eastern Ukraine. Most importantly, those deals envisioned to take away the control (or even access) Russia (and the local population, for that matter) have/had over these resources. If anyone annexed anything, it was rather the USA than Russia. The key on all that is to observe which side was the one taking all the initiatives, and which side was basically just responding to what the other side did. This fear mongering about Russian expansion simply doesn't match reality. If anyone has been expanding the last decade or so, it is NATO, not Russia. In reality, it probably should not surprise anyone. It's a well proven tactic to simply accuse your victims of being the one showing aggression, while in reality that is just resistance to your own (illegal) aggression. Just ask some of the older Poles. They still remember what Germany did.
- jonathanstrange 6y agoIt was an invasion and annexation according to international law. That is crystal clear and there is not even any leeway for interpretation about it. On a side note, the kind of justifications / rationalization you give for the annexation - somebody installed politicians there that were not pleasing Russia enough - are not only factually incorrect, too, they are also irrelevant to the question whether the Crimea was annexed by Russia or not. I don't know where you think the "green men" militia came from, but I know for certain that they were Russian military (and no, not on vacation). And let's not forget that a Buk system was provided directly from Russia that then downed Malaysia Airlines Flight 17, killing all 283 crew and passengers. Dutch authorities and international investigators have uncovered and documented every single minute of this crime, from the arrival of the BUK system to its hasty departure afterwards, and identified the Russian officers involved in it by name and picture. These are the facts.
- boomboomsubban 6y agoIf we don't frame things as countries needing to ally with the US out of fear of Russia\China, we may have to realize that countries are forced to ally with the US as the ones that don't end up overthrown or facing endless economic warfare like Venezuela/Iran.
- themihai 6y agoThe beauty is that we don't need to even think about that. Russia and China are bad actors anyway so in a way you could say they are strengthening the alliance between U.S and EU. Also EU is neither Venezuela nor Iran.
- VBprogrammer 6y agoI think part of this narrative is the US spends an incredible amount on the military. If they don't continue to cast the entire world as with us or against us then that amount of money becomes harder to justify.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- themihai 6y ago>> Russia is not USSR But it wants the Soviet Union back. >> and is not a threat to anyone Ukraine would not agree with that. Russia took Crimea and is supporting a civil war in eastern Ukraine. This may not be much for you but >> except immediate neighbors Yeah except the immediate neighbours and then the neighbours of the neighbours. Think of the Soviet Union era... Speaking of neighbours Denmark, Sweden, Lithuania and few others are pretty close to Russia. I guess they are on your list of doomed neighbours anyway.
- koheripbal 6y agoThis is an important thing to note about Europe - they don't really care about the security of other European nations. There's no sense of unity. If there were, they would collectively take a much much harder stance with Russia. This is why Eastern Europe is so much more pro-USA than Western Europe.
- themihai 6y agoyeah it's still everyone for themselves. "Take back control" and "sovereignty" seems to win the more points than "solidarity" or "unity" in the political discourse of many EU countries.
- coldtea 6y ago>Ukraine would not agree with that. Russia took Crimea and is supporting a civil war in eastern Ukraine. This may not be much for you but Crimea was part of Russia for centuries, it has 60%+ citizens of Russian ethnicity, and it had its government toppled and neo-nazis and nationalists come to power in a NATO proxy power play. It would be like Mexico having an area (say Baja California) with 60% WASP Americans, that has been historically part of the US, and having Mexico's government toppled with the help of a foreign superpower and used against the US. Would the US annex Baja California then? Then again, the US have already annexed Texas, Florida, California, New Mexico, Arizona, etc, from Mexico, so there's that...
- rini17 6y ago
- wil421 6y agoWhat about Ukraine? Surely Russia’s not a threat to them at all.
- virgilp 6y agoSurely Ukraine qualifies as "immediate neighbor"?