4 ms·
RPC DRAM support in open source DRAM controller
- ohazi 6y agoSize comparison: https://twitter.com/GregDavill/status/1300562224474279936?s=19 https://twitter.com/GregDavill/status/1300562224474279936?s=...
- fest 6y agoSidenote: LiteX is awesome. Knowing next to nothing about it, I was able to create a customized system-on-chip with RiscV CPU, several SPI/UART/I2C buses, load it on a devboard and blink some LEDs in an evening or two. The resulting Socs have been shown to boot Linux (albeit, slowly).
- elcritch 6y agoThat's impressive, and could lower the cost of entry for a lot of hardware projects.
- fest 6y agoI don't see it as lowering the cost of entry much (i.e. FPGA chip with reasonable number of gates for Linux is on the order of 50EUR/pc, and general purpose CPU performance is not even remotely close to, let's say Allwinner or Rockchip ARM SoC), but as something that either opens up new possibilities as a whole (for example, a trusted computing platform, where you can actually verify that no backdoors exist- see https://www.bunniestudios.com/blog/?p=5971 https://www.bunniestudios.com/blog/?p=5971 ) or something that provides unprecedented flexibility in the future proofness of embedded designs: for example when you realize that you need another UART in a product that's been shipping for 5 years, and the MCU family you have been using just does not have the part you need. I am particularly excited about the hardware flexibility- it seems a very good platform for scientific/engineering instrumentation (LiteX actually seems to be conceived because of this niche).
- elcritch 6y ago> I am particularly excited about the hardware flexibility- it seems a very good platform for scientific/engineering instrumentation (LiteX actually seems to be conceived because of this niche). That's doubly exciting! Yes it's great to see new possibilities opening up. The cost reduction I mean is the lowering the development costs for custom platforms. If you need a team of expert hardware designers to design this stuff then most labs/small companies will be "priced out" of that arena.
- fest 6y agoOh yes, it can bring the cost of design and development down, agreed.
- pjc50 6y agoThat's an unfortunately heavily overloaded name, the FPGA builder is way down the search results behind the football club and the swimwear vendor.
- FullyFunctional 6y agoI love RPC; it’s much better utilization of pins - same bandwidth over 22 as over ~ 45, IOW about twice the bandwidth per pin. Downside is a slightly higher latency because address and command have to travel over them too, but this is amortized over the burst transfer. The real problem with RPC is that devices has tiny capacity; 256 Mb today and max spec’ed to 8 Gb (yes, I am aware that they consider it a feature, but I don’t). Also, it’s actually pretty expensive today compared to regular DRAM.
- castratikron 6y agoGuessing address pins have been replaced with SPI or something similar?
- FullyFunctional 6y agoThat would have been terrible. No, they have effectively routed the address/mask information over the data bus and eliminated those signals. Yes it takes multiple beats, but it's at least not bit serial.
- rowanG077 6y agoI want to love the litex components but I have only ever had problems with them. Never gotten liteeth or litedram to work.