3 ms·
> We have to rely on some sort of proxy for the simplicity or elegance of the theory in order to preclude hypotheses like the above. No, we don't. The rule tha
by pdonis 6y ago
> We have to rely on some sort of proxy for the simplicity or elegance of the theory in order to preclude hypotheses like the above.
No, we don't. The rule that precludes your hypothesis is much simpler: the laws of physics don't change with time. That doesn't require the laws of physics to be "simple" or "elegant", and doesn't require anyone's subjective judgment about which laws of physics they think are more beautiful.
- whatshisface 6y ago>The rule that precludes your hypothesis is much simpler: the laws of physics don't change with time Why should we believe this rule?
- mannykannot 6y agoYou can believe what you like - science is not concerned with persuading every skeptic.
- whimsicalism 6y agoThe point isn't skepticism of science, it's the recognition that something akin to Occam's Razor has to be used in theory, as there will always be an infinite number of unfalsifiable theories for any set of observations. In this context, Sabine is the skeptic of theory writ large. So many replies taking my argument to be the exact opposite of what it is.
- mannykannot 6y agoMy post above was a specific response to whatshisface's comment, saying that science need not, and will not, be hobbled by inordinate skepicism (which, if persued consistently, collapses into useless solipsism.) In this particular case, science adopts the idea of unchanging laws as a methodological assumption rather than an axiom. Similarly, science need not, and will not, be hobbled by the "infinite number of unfalsifiable theories" that you raise. In effect, science tables all these fanciful objections unless and until circumstances and evidence make them relevant. Scence is not metaphysics - it is not attempting to deduce how the world must be; it is trying to find out how it is, and so the sort of arguments that philosophers get entangled in (such as "possible worlds" arguments which ultimately reduce to what a given philosopher can imagine) don't carry much weight. This is not just "something akin" to Occam's razor; it is precisely that, and it is not a vague preference for "beauty" or "elegance". Elsewhere, Hossenfelder made an insightful comment about falsifiability, along the lines that falsifiability is just table stakes for a hypothesis to make the grade as a theory, and not a guarantor of merit.