3 ms·
The problem is that the scales are completely unbalanced when it comes to information vs misinformation. There is political and financial incentives at play to
by cogman10 6y ago
The problem is that the scales are completely unbalanced when it comes to information vs misinformation.
There is political and financial incentives at play to spread misinformation. It isn't as simple as "the best ideas win" as most social media platforms make it REALLY easy to manipulate the narrative.
For example, if some politician will negatively impact my business, I can hire a BUNCH of people to go out and write nasty comments about that politician. I can create fake media pages to support whatever narrative I want against that candidate. I can do all of this for relatively little money. We see this phenomenon come up time and time again when it comes to review websites. Most people "in the know" don't trust amazon reviews because they know companies astroturf them like crazy.
Climate change is a place where this also happens a LOT. Man made climate change is a nearly undisputed fact in the scientific world, yet roughly half of Americans either don't believe in it or are unsure about it. Why? Because there's big incentives behind the fossil fuel industry to spread FUD and misinformation about climate change. On the flip side, there's just not the money or resources available to climate scientists to correct that narrative.
I can buy that "some censorship doesn't work" however, it appears that a free for all is equally broken.
- l33tbro 6y agoPopulation size and distrust of authority have a fairly linear relationship. The bigger we get, the further from power and decision-making we feel we are. This makes a great case for no censorship. Of course, the gremlins created by the above scenario makes a great case for some censorship. Until authority can be coaxed into becoming more transparent and, thereby, creating trust, we will keep having this conversation.
- nickthemagicman 6y agoThe only thing that works is trusting humans to be smart enough to make their own decisions and not forcing rules upon them.