3 ms·
You lead a charmed life, my friend. Many designers I have known think of consistency in terms of branding (at most). There is almost always some weird edge cas
by zdragnar 6y ago
You lead a charmed life, my friend.
Many designers I have known think of consistency in terms of branding (at most). There is almost always some weird edge case that means a new font size, or unique spacing. Get enough of those, and the design system falls apart.
Some are better than others at this, obviously, but the mix has not really been in consistency's favor (though I will admit it has been improving the past few years).
- wildrhythms 6y ago(not the person you're replying to) This is so true, and thanks for introducing me to Adam Wathan's Youtube channel, I had no idea this existed. I work closely with designers who use tools like Sketch, Framer, Figma, etc and I'm always finding little edge cases where their "pixel perfect" designs have mismatched paddings, margins, often half-pixel letter spacing that they've decided is more aesthetic in their design tool. It can be hard to push back sometimes.
- trevyn 6y agoI think this gets to the core of the problem -- we need a design tool that can directly export fully styled React components (or whatever). Basically, we're asking workaday designers to design using a tool that doesn't respect the implementation constraints, and doesn't allow them to preview at arbitrary window sizes.
- tomhallett 6y agoNote: I didn't say "they love it so much that they follow it religiously and never break from it". :) While I don't disagree with your points, there is still ground to be made here. 1) If designers had a "tailwind linter" in their design tool from the start, I believe that they would be encouraged to use it from the start and would start tweaking their designs from the get go to look just as good with it. The same principle applies to code linters. There are exceptions where developers can disable a linter for specific pieces of code, but having it there encourages the code to be "constrained" in a consistent way. 2) Just because a design has a "13px" padding doesn't imply the designer thought "13 pixels is the best value here and 12 pixels is simply unacceptable". A design linter would help with the "expressiveness" of the design and when things truly are "exceptional" cases. Note 2: I'm obviously recommending a technical solution to the problem very early in the design process, but the way I solve it now is by discussing it with the designer over a zoom call. I'll show them the design and say "does this look good? I deviated a bit, is that ok?" It almost always is, which is a win for everyone.