4 ms·
People love to paint this world of voluntary transactions and consensual agreements, but then corporations turn around and push for right-to-work laws which inf
by whimsicalism 6y ago
People love to paint this world of voluntary transactions and consensual agreements, but then corporations turn around and push for right-to-work laws which infringe freedom of association and contract by making it illegal for companies to sign security clause contracts with Unions.
Why should a voluntary, consensual signing of a contract be made illegal?
- renewiltord 6y agoIt most certainly should not. In fact, I'd say we shouldn't weaken labour rights before we undo that.
- JAlexoid 6y agoMandated unions, union bans and laws undermining union contracts - are all infringements on freedom of association.
- whimsicalism 6y ago> Mandated unions Unions aren't mandated by law anywhere.
- bumby 6y agoAren’t they mandated in non-right-to-work states in union shops?
- whimsicalism 6y agoNo, the company has voluntarily entered into a contract to only hire through the union. They could have not entered into such an agreement but voluntarily chose to do so, and nobody was mandated to join a union, as all job offers are also voluntarily accepted.
- bumby 6y agoI meant from the perspective of the employee. If there’s a contract in place in a non-right-to-work state, you must join the union. The “just find a different job” position is the trivial case that doesn’t really add much to the discussion
- whimsicalism 6y agoThere is no law requiring you join a union in any state. It might be that you have to join a union upon being hired for a job, just like I had to waive my right to sue my employer in a court of law (rather than an arbitrator) in order to accept my current job. I was never mandated to do so, at least not in the way that right-to-work laws mandate that employers can't sign security clauses with unions because they would go to jail or be fined.
- bumby 6y agoI conceded the point that there's no law, but am trying to make the point that from a pragmatic policy perspective it's a trivial point that isn't helpful. Union security clauses cut both ways; they also require employees to join said union as long as the contract is active. You can't perform the job and be non-union. "If you don't like the job, don't take it." It's like the argument when discussing child welfare policy where one side says "Don't ask society to help; if you need help, don't have kids". Or in healthcare policy, "Don't want high medical bills? Buy better insurance." While true, it is just a way to elevate above the actual problem without providing a satisfactory policy solution.
- whimsicalism 6y ago> Union security clauses cut both ways; they also require employees to join said union as long as the contract is active. You can't perform the job and be non-union. I guess I don't see why an employer requiring you to join a union upon joining the job is a. a mandate (it's not) b. at all different from any number of things that an employer can require you to sign off on to start working at a job. Union membership is "mandated" in the same way that when you accept a job that requires a 40 hrs/week, you are "mandated" to go to work. > the actual problem What is the actual problem? I don't see union security clauses as a problem, it's basically the only way collective bargaining can solve the free-rider problem and generally benefits the worker.
- JAlexoid 6y agoThat's literally not true.