5 ms·
Companies can't stop you from unionizing. They can choose not to accept the collective agreement and they can hire permanent replacement for strikers. As for w
by renewiltord 6y ago
Companies can't stop you from unionizing. They can choose not to accept the collective agreement and they can hire permanent replacement for strikers.
As for whether anyone should have a problem, you're welcome to have a problem. It's a free country. Whether that will lead to an outcome you desire is independent, though.
- jasonjayr 6y agoYou're right; but all too often companies turn to government to pass laws weakening unions, rather than continue to negotiate in good faith.
- JAlexoid 6y agoThat's a great argument for reducing government's power.
- whoknew1122 6y ago> "Companies can't stop you from unionizing." de jure != de facto Companies are legally prohibited from stopping unionization in the US. But that's not how it works in reality. Most people work in an 'at-will' states. This means a company can terminate employees at any time. Want to unionize? Have at it. All an employer needs to do is find is some company policy a person is violating (and trust me, EVERYONE is violates their company's policies from time-to-time, if only because company policies are so verbose and onerous). Your work badge isn't immediately visible? That's a policy violation. Go over your lunch a few minutes? That's a policy violation. The company fires the unionizer. Now the onous is on the fired employee to prove that they were fired for unionizing. As long as the company doesn't say "I fired you because you were unionizing" (which they would never do), you got a lengthy legal battle on your hands. Now where do you take your battle? To the NLRB. Now you have to fight against regulatory capture and political appointees who are hostile to the very idea of organized labor. Even if you do win, it will cost untold sums of time and money. It will be years before everything is adjudicated. At that point, what does it matter? The unionizer has been forced to move onto another job in the interim (and hope that the other company doesn't avoid hiring the person because of the labor complaint. And if the potential employer does? Another legal battle that the unionizer has to enter and prove).
- pc86 6y agoSo what is your suggestion then
- whoknew1122 6y agoWe could start with: 1.) Getting rid of at-will employment 2.) Have a NLRB that is functional and actually protects labor 3.) Lower the legal threshold for proving illicit anti-union activities 4.) Give teeth to laws protect that unionization and uniformly enforce those laws no matter the political party in power 5.) Staff the upper levels of the NLRB with career civil servants, not political appointees
- whimsicalism 6y agoHonestly, I would start with just a. eliminating workplace one-party consent recording laws in every state b. public advertising campaign + bounty - record your employer for violation of labor law and get paid a bounty if it is proven in court
- whimsicalism 6y agotwo-party* shit
- JAlexoid 6y agoIf you terminate at-will employment, then as a service provider I demand that we terminate at-will purchasing.
- xav0989 6y agoCompanies can't stop you from unionizing, but as Walmart has shown time and again, they will straight up close a store and lay-off every employee there if there are rumours of unionization. They would rather not have a store at all than have a store where the employees are unionized.
- JAlexoid 6y agoOk... Is there a law somewhere that says that you have a right to have a Walmart? As an anarchist - why are people not willing to start a co-op?
- bumby 6y agoShort answer: people have limited bandwidth and are forced to pick their battles. Open your refrigerator, look in your closet. Can you say with certainty that you voted with your wallet by only supporting companies that adhere to your values? Today’s economy has too many interactions to have any confidence about how you vote with your wallet. In this case complexity, not religion, is the opiate of the masses. Most people’s lives are too complex and busy to “start a co-op”. I know the counter argument is probably “then they obviously don’t care enough” but that’s the pragmatic answer
- JAlexoid 6y agoWell... The answer isn't to force Walmart to provide a service to them.
- bumby 6y agoI don't know if you're strawmanning on purpose or missing the point. I also don't think the answer is "the market will just sort it out...eventually." Of course there is no law mandating Walmart provide a service. There are, however, laws governing how Walmart must treat employees. Part of their bad reputation is that they run afoul of these laws. I know the anarchist view is to just decide not to shop there. My point is that in a pragmatic sense, consumers in a globalized economy cannot assess all the information to do so, even if it was freely available. The counterargument is that regulators are the better alternative, which is why the Dept. of Labor has fined them in the past to correct that behavior.
- whimsicalism 6y agoPeople love to paint this world of voluntary transactions and consensual agreements, but then corporations turn around and push for right-to-work laws which infringe freedom of association and contract by making it illegal for companies to sign security clause contracts with Unions. Why should a voluntary, consensual signing of a contract be made illegal?
- renewiltord 6y agoIt most certainly should not. In fact, I'd say we shouldn't weaken labour rights before we undo that.
- JAlexoid 6y agoMandated unions, union bans and laws undermining union contracts - are all infringements on freedom of association.
- whimsicalism 6y ago> Mandated unions Unions aren't mandated by law anywhere.
- bumby 6y agoAren’t they mandated in non-right-to-work states in union shops?
- whimsicalism 6y agoNo, the company has voluntarily entered into a contract to only hire through the union. They could have not entered into such an agreement but voluntarily chose to do so, and nobody was mandated to join a union, as all job offers are also voluntarily accepted.
- bumby 6y agoI meant from the perspective of the employee. If there’s a contract in place in a non-right-to-work state, you must join the union. The “just find a different job” position is the trivial case that doesn’t really add much to the discussion
- goodpoint 6y ago> Companies can't stop you from unionizing Companies have been fighting unions for a century. In some cases leading to massacres: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homestead_strike https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homestead_strike