26 ms·
the whole point of antitrust regulations is that > Both Apple and Google are fully within their rights to charge whatever they want within their app store and
by baq 6y ago
the whole point of antitrust regulations is that
> Both Apple and Google are fully within their rights to charge whatever they want within their app store and enforce whatever capricious whims they like on apps that they distribute.
actually isn't always true - especially when it hurts consumers. of course it isn't up to us here to decide if it does. remember that private doesn't mean unregulated.
- zaroth 6y agoJust look at what Apple has accomplished in the meteoric rise of the iPhone. This is strong evidence of a company that is competing like hell to keep and grow its customers base. “Hurting consumers” would be an almost Orwellian characterization of the smartphone technology revolution driven predominantly by the competition between Apple, Samsung, Google, Huawei, etc.
- whimsicalism 6y ago> a company that is competing like hell The problem is when by "competing like hell", you compete so hard that you suppress your competition. The issue that anti-competition laws seek to redress is the suppression of other competition.
- zaroth 6y agoExcept the competition isn’t suppressed, and there’s no actual monopoly here. What we have is a pretty clear case of a minuscule minority of users bitterly complaining that a company isn’t making its products exactly the way they want them to. A store is allowed to charge what it wants for its products. A store is allowed to set the policies that it wants for the goods that it sells in its own stores. It just so happens that Apple’s customers absolutely love its products, and that Apple’s products are absolute technological leaders in their space. Apple didn’t get there, e.g. like Facebook by buying up the competition any time it started to emerge as a threat. They got there through decades of focused development and investment.
- whimsicalism 6y ago> A store is allowed to charge what it wants for its products. A store is allowed to set the policies that it wants for the goods that it sells in its own stores. A store is allowed to block you from using any other store? These aren't natural continuations or logical extensions of meatspace, stop pretending they are.
- zaroth 6y agoThis is literally not what’s happening. The iPhone is their product. If you don’t want to use their products and their store you do not have to. Buy a different device. There are plenty. Apple doesn’t get to tell Google, Samsung, Huawei, LG, OnePlus, Fairphone, etc. how to build their devices. The one device they do get to decide how it works is the iPhone. Because they created it, they own it, and they get to decide its future. Their device, their decision. The consumer gets to decide if they like it or not. Overwhelmingly, they decide that they do.
- whimsicalism 6y agoYou're making normative claims as if they are "the way things are." Maybe the above is how you think things ought to be (I disagree), but anti-trust jurisprudence does not agree with your pseudo-libertarian worldview.
- zaroth 6y agoMaybe we can both at least agree the normative claims I’m making are true absent a monopoly finding. Anti-trust only applies if there’s a finding that Apple is a monopoly. The jury, so to speak, is still out. If Apple was found to be a monopoly, then there may need to be some restrictions placed on how they operate. But I think controlling how your own product works is the presumed default, even if that product is wildly successful, as long as that success is through actual product merit, and not done deceptively or through illegal collusion.
- 6y ago
- baq 6y agoreplace 'apple' with 'standard oil', 'iphone' with 'kerosene' and '2020' with '1900'.
- indigochill 6y ago> of course it isn't up to us here to decide if it does I also think it shouldn't be up to courts. It should be up to the consumers themselves. They generally seem quite happy with Apple and Google. On the other hand, if there is a consumer need that is not being met by Google or Apple, it is a prime opportunity to disrupt the market with a new offering that fulfills that need. If Google or Apple stamp that out or have done so in the past, then I will agree it's an anti-competition issue.
- whimsicalism 6y agoWell glad we live in a country with laws and not a pseudo-libertarian "all governance by consumer choice" world. Regardless of what you think "should" happen, the reality is that you massively understated the scope of the applicable law.
- arrosenberg 6y agoThe point is that Apple and Google have used their market power in other verticals (hardware, services) to lock all other competitors out of the mobile app distribution market. They are acting as private regulators of who can publish a mobile app, which is unacceptable if we still claim to support competitive, public markets. How would a consumer even know if they were happy given the lack of options? Are they actually happy, or do they just have bigger issues to worry about? That's why we hire experts to act as regulators for new industries.