6 ms·
> - Start by implementing a odd/even rule for license plates in big cities, even full bans on weekends. > - Tax and/or de-subsidize the meat industry. And jus
by echelon 6y ago
> - Start by implementing a odd/even rule for license plates in big cities, even full bans on weekends.
> - Tax and/or de-subsidize the meat industry.
And just like that, you've been voted straight out of office. Better luck next life connecting to the electorate.
You can't do those things. Humanity is a distributed consensus problem. Climate change presents an interesting change in the fitness landscape topology ahead.
- arnoooooo 6y agoWhat are leaders for if they can't lead ? Should their job not be to convince people of what needs to be done ? They do a very good job by the way when it comes to pushing for liberalism.
- singemonkey 6y agoWhen did Trump and Johnson push for liberalism?
- black_puppydog 6y agoThen humanity is clearly headed off a cliff in that landscape. Which, by the way, has been signaled to everyone for decades now. Just our political processes have not allowed those signals to reach "the economy" and we seem to be unable to act on anything that isn't felt by the economy. Which, I might add, is not a god-given fact, but rather a political choice. Anyway, we will have a cliff. And it will have been announced. And people will suffer when our consensus finding process drives us all over this cliff.
- rusk 6y ago> political processes have not allowed those signals to reach "the economy" This right here is the achilles heal of free market theory.
- baq 6y agothe market can and will correct itself. there are two problems however: - actually getting rules implemented and enforced (political suicide by regulators - had an example of that in my own country just a couple months ago, made a mess in the government, the new rules didn't pass in parliament, governing party lost 10 pp in polls anyway) - very irregular period of convergence from old rules to new (societal turmoil guaranteed, political consequences very likely) - see thatcher's closure of British coal mines for a good example
- black_puppydog 6y agoyou forgot problem number three: - the market as such will correct itself but is entirely unconcerned with the welfare of human beings in the meantime, and will continue to be unconcerned with it afterwards.
- baq 6y agoactually that was my point in problem 2...
- rusk 6y agoSounds like no true Scotsman
- ryandrake 6y ago> Which, by the way, has been signaled to everyone for decades now. That's part of the problem. The general public have been hearing it for decades now, and are probably just sick and tired of hearing about it. As far back as I can remember, it's been nothing but "Nuclear weapons are gonna kill us all" "Acid rain is gonna kill us all!" "Smog is gonna kill us all!" "Drugs and crime are gonna kill us all" "The ozone hole is gonna kill us all!" "Global warming is gonna kill us all!" "Terrorism is gonna kill us all" "Climate change is gonna kill us all!" Yet, here we are, still going on towards these various cliffs. I can at least put myself in the general public's shoes for a bit and empathize with their crisis fatigue. Economic crises are felt immediately--you lose your job. It's no surprise that it's politically easier to favor economics over other crises that are perpetually happening Real Soon Now.
- black_puppydog 6y agoI'm not necessarily disagreeing with the diagnosis of "crisis fatigue" but for the examples you give, here's a breakdown by my own very biased view. I'm leaving out Acid Rain because I never really was part of that discourse (too young) and didn't read about it after the fact either. These four (IMHO) do actually pose clear and present dangers to human health & wellbeing at scale: * Nuclear Weapons * Smog * Ozone * Global Warming / Climate Change They were identified as risks and (except for Ozone, which was actually tackled and is improving to my knowlege) continue to be shown as risks. Or rather, by now, as actually doing harm. On the other hand, these two here were never the big catastrophes that they were made out to be, yet were (and are!) continually overblown. * Drugs & Crime * Terrorism Neither of them ever had the existential threat potential that the other group had. Not-so-incidentally, the proposed "solutions" to these problems were always... * highly profitable for certain industries * useful for conservative re-elections * based in little to no fact * often (predictably) counter-productive. Bottom line: if we had actually put time and money into existing, working solutions to measurable, actual problems, we would have been perfectly capable to do so. We did it for Ozone, we could have done it again. We didn't. Instead, we put countless dollars and lives into "solving" problems that were pretty much caused by their "solutions", and mostly because that was in the best interest of very few people. If people are tired of anything, I hope/suspect that they are tired of a political/economic system that predictably ended up producing this mess.
- plutonorm 6y agoAbsolutely correct. And this is probably the "great filter". Unless we do something now we are headed down a very bad road. Our only option is going to be geo-engineering which is a risky business
- smilekzs 6y ago> odd/even rule for license plates Friendly reminder that Beijing has been implementing exactly that, then later a variant of that, since 2008. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Road_space_rationing_in_Beijing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Road_space_rationing_in_Beijin...
- jphoward 6y agoExactly, the prototypical example has implemented it is one without democratic elections and so has no risk of being voted out of office.
- input_sh 6y agoFriendly reminder that measures like this unevenly affect people in different social classes, because those who are well-off can just buy two cars and be completely unaffected.
- smilekzs 6y agoTo that end Beijing also implements a car registration quota per year where applicants are randomly picked
- dzhiurgis 6y agoI'm not sure it's so easy to buy second car in Beijing. Anything is possible if you are very rich, but that doesn't matter if there's a 1% more cars instead of 50%.
- diegoholiveira 6y agoThis is done in Sao Paulo since 1996 and yes, people have two cars, usually middle class and up. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vehicle_restriction_in_S%C3%A3o_Paulo https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vehicle_restriction_in_S%C3%...
- CaptArmchair 6y agoOf course you can't do them storming straight out of the gates. It just doesn't work like that. But sure, you can do them perfectly. How? - You provide incentives for attractive alternatives. - You invest in those alternatives and you invest in contextual drivers that make the transition more appealing. For instance, you provide an integrated plans for urban planning that cover different concerns. - You emphasize the benefits of those alternatives on an individual level. - You make a compelling narrative why the status quo is holding the individual back. - You diversify your narrative to to identify / appeal with as many different social groups as you have to. That's just the content. Then there's also your political position. Whether your part of a power elite, or your not, you still need tactics to garner support, whether you like it or not. Alinsky's 12 rules for radicals, for instance, is a classic example in that regard. The automative industry or the meat industry didn't just happen simply because individual consumers out of their own accord. They also happened because consumers where incentivized to buy in a 'modern' lifestyle with a heavy focus on cheap and convenience during the 20th century as opposed to more traditional, localized ways of living; and because those industries that supported this cultural shift were directly and indirectly subsidized. For instance, cities got covered in highway infrastructure in the 1950's and 1960's paid for through public funding and public policy making. Public governance is about figuring out feedback loops in social, economical and political dynamics and finding ways to bend them towards your agenda. Banning cars in city centers is already happening in European cities. The usual argument is to make living in the city more comfortable or make the city more attractive for commerce driven by regional or international tourism (both of which having their own drawbacks and tensions).
- mytailorisrich 6y agoPeople used to eat little meat, not because of a "traditional" or "localized" way of living but because they were too poor to afford it. As soon as they got richer they could do what they dreamed of. It's like cars, really. People used to walk. Not because it was nice and healthy but because they had no choice. Then bikes and public transport werean improvement, but really people do prefer the comfort and freedom of driving their own cars and when that became possible and affordable they did not need much convincing to jump at the opportunity.