4 ms·
I just checked and Pyongyang is 150 km from the border and 45 km from the coast. Korea is a small place. This can definitely be done in both directions.
by oblio 6y ago
I just checked and Pyongyang is 150 km from the border and 45 km from the coast. Korea is a small place.
This can definitely be done in both directions.
- mulmen 6y agoIt can only be done in both directions. That's the entire basis of the conflict, and of NK's foreign policy for the last three generations.
- vertis 6y agoThis doesn't make sense. Seoul is at risk because it is very close to the border where-as Pyongyang is much further from their mutual border. There are, of course, other considerations, but Seoul would be very difficult to defend from 'simple' weapons like artillery. The US is very proud of it's ability to fire artillery 40 miles (64km), but Pyongyang is much further than that.
- mulmen 6y agoIf NK attacks SK then the US will obliterate NK. The US does not need to use artillery to obliterate Pyongyang. Pyongyang cannot be defended against US weapons. Seoul and allies cannot defend against NK weapons.
- vertis 6y agoThis completely misses the point of the GP (or is that GGP) though. It's not a debate whether NK could survive, it couldn't, but Seoul is indefensible. Everything I've read suggests the Seoul is a casualty of any conflict. Regardless of the eventual 'winner'.
- mulmen 6y agoI haven't said anything to the contrary. I'm not sure what you found confusing.
- vertis 6y agoI don't think we're in disagreement, I just think we're focusing on different things. In any case, I think we've beat this one to death. :)
- SEJeff 6y agoPrecisely this. There is no real winner in war (I'm a US Army Veteran of OIF II circa 2003-2004), only one side that might lose less. Taking a life breaks many people, even trained infantry. Look at all of the veteran suicides due to PTSD from war as proof of this. Once someone on either side has been killed in war, both sides permanently lose. There are no take-backs, only damaged soldiers on both sides and casualties.
- m4rtink 6y agoThere is some work being done on shooting down artilery and mortar projectiles & Iron Dome deployed in Israel regularly shoots down small unguided missiles.
- avar 6y agoIt can't be done in both directions. The reference to Seul's proximity to the border is that it's within the range of North Korean artillery. The reverse isn't true.
- mulmen 6y agoWhy would SK and allies use the same weapons as NK instead of the far more advanced (capable) weapons SK and allies possess? Both Seoul and Pyongyang are within range of their adversaries' weapons.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- avar 6y agoYes of course, the US has had the technical ability to glass North Korea since the 50s or 60s, but that's not the "it" we're talking about here. The point oblio is maintaining upthread is that because SK and her allies have much more advanced weaponry NK doesn't have a chance of standing against them in a conventional conflict. That's true, but misses the point. Before NK had nuclear weapons one of their main deterrents was that they'd had years/decades to fortify conventional artillery at the border pointed at Seul. So even if their military couldn't stand a chance in a conventional war they could plausibly threaten MAD by holding Seul hostage. That's the context in which the border proximity is brought up. Replying to that by saying that Pyongyang is 150 km from the border or whatever is irrelevant. Yes of course the US could win an all-out conventional war with an enemy 50, 150 or 1500 km from its border. That was never in question. The question was whether a relatively weaker enemy could present an outsized threat due to some strategic geographic position. That's been the case with NK precisely because mid-century artillery technology can be dug-in close enough to the border to matter. Whereas if the border happened to be 150 km away those assets could be taken out by missiles once they tried to move in position to shoot on a major target like Seul. Whether the NK artillery actually poses a strategic threat is another matter. I wouldn't be surprised if it's all mapped out be the US/SK and would be taken out in the first 5 minutes of a conflict by targeted missile attacks. But it's not just a strategic question, but whether e.g. NK can make threats that are taken seriously by the SK population for it to pressure its government to make some concessions to NK.