7 ms·
I don't know the local details, but I would be very surprised if a fully industrialized developed nation such as South Korea doesn't have a full military arsena
by oblio 6y ago
I don't know the local details, but I would be very surprised if a fully industrialized developed nation such as South Korea doesn't have a full military arsenal pointed right back at the agrarian, backwards North Korea. Especially since several of the Korean chaebols have quite advanced military arms.
South Korea would obviously wants support from the US and the rest of the world, but I'm pretty sure they can flatten North Korea right back if they're fired upon.
- jacobush 6y agoYes, what’s your point exactly? It’s still a bargaining chip.
- oblio 6y agoMy point is that everyone treats South Korea as being a 8 year old in a bad neighborhood. As crazy as North Korea is, if they fire first, South Korea isn't just a sitting duck. North Korea would probably be obliterated just from South Korea hitting back, let alone if anyone else allied to South Korea jumps in. Micro scale MAD. North Korea is just grandstanding for food, it doesn't really mean that they will follow through. I mean, they're a dictatorship, so who knows.
- baybal2 6y agoWhen people speak North Korea, they speak China. If China will say "jump" to Kim, he will, for as long as the physical security of Kim's family is provided (which is pretty much the one, and only carrot China been using with them)
- mulmen 6y agoIf the Korean peninsula goes hot again tens of millions of South Koreans will die within days. Probably within hours. There's no doubt the US and allies will be victorious, barring massive strategic blunders, but there's also no way to prevent horrific levels of destruction. To say nothing of China stepping in and kicking off WWIII.
- mytailorisrich 6y agoConsidering the nuclear arsenals in place and the fact that no-one has anything to gain, any discussion about a conflict with North Korea is academic at best.
- jacobush 6y agoThere has been an awful lot of "academic" skirmishes involving real live fire in that conflict over the years. Each one of these is playing a little with fire. Sometimes, things escalate for no rational reason.
- mytailorisrich 6y agoNot at all. Everyone knows what they are doing and those skirmishes are to make specific points. No-one is going to start an actual war.
- mdiesel 6y agoYes, and Archduke Franz Ferdinand was shot in Sarajevo to make a specific point, the point had nothing to do with the war we ended up with. It's naïve to say "we were just trying to make the point X, we didn't think it would escalate" when the actors involved have the resources and incentive to react with interest.
- mytailorisrich 6y agoFull-scale wars are not started by accident, certainly not when 3 or 4 countries involved have nuclear weapons, not least North Korea itself. If anything North Korea developing its own nuclear arsenal took war off the table. That was the point, although full-scale war was probably already off the table, but a more limited action to topple the regime probably wasn't. It's borderline madness to suggest otherwise.
- 6y ago
- ekianjo 6y agoSouth Korea would be completely destroyed with the first attack by NK anyway (if talking about WMD), so not sure what you are trying to say here.
- goatinaboat 6y agoSouth Korea would be completely destroyed with the first attack by NK anyway (if talking about WMD) NK has enough completely conventional artillery in range of Seoul to deliver a Hiroshima level attack. Their WMD programme is about deterring outsiders.
- foota 6y agoIt's not a question of who would win, but NK could indiscriminately bombard Seoul, which is very close to the border. This could kill millions of people and destroy the economic center of SK.
- oblio 6y agoI just checked and Pyongyang is 150 km from the border and 45 km from the coast. Korea is a small place. This can definitely be done in both directions.
- mulmen 6y agoIt can only be done in both directions. That's the entire basis of the conflict, and of NK's foreign policy for the last three generations.
- vertis 6y agoThis doesn't make sense. Seoul is at risk because it is very close to the border where-as Pyongyang is much further from their mutual border. There are, of course, other considerations, but Seoul would be very difficult to defend from 'simple' weapons like artillery. The US is very proud of it's ability to fire artillery 40 miles (64km), but Pyongyang is much further than that.
- mulmen 6y agoIf NK attacks SK then the US will obliterate NK. The US does not need to use artillery to obliterate Pyongyang. Pyongyang cannot be defended against US weapons. Seoul and allies cannot defend against NK weapons.
- vertis 6y agoThis completely misses the point of the GP (or is that GGP) though. It's not a debate whether NK could survive, it couldn't, but Seoul is indefensible. Everything I've read suggests the Seoul is a casualty of any conflict. Regardless of the eventual 'winner'.
- totalZero 6y agoFiring back is not a solution to being fired upon. It's a deterrent. A deterrent is not very effective if the thing it's intended to deter actually happens.
- mulmen 6y agoA fitting username for a completely accurate comment.
- eatbitseveryday 6y agoThis sounds like something I would read on reddit, your comment.
- mulmen 6y agoYeah I was having a bad day.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rezeroed 6y agoThat sounds like you're dismissing the concepts of self-defence and retaliation.
- orestarod 6y agoIt is obviously not a deterrent if you are not willing to follow through with it. The word you are looking for in that case is not "deterrent", but "bluff".
- vmh1928 6y agoThe problem is that a significant portion of the South Korean civilian population lives within range of NK artillery in place along the DMZ including parts of the capitol, Seoul. According to this article that's about 45 miles. https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/2017/world/mapping-the-dmz/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/2017/world/mapping-t...