3 ms·
Thos post if based off some serious misunderstandings, two main flaws: 1 - Subs are the ultimate trump card, the rest of the triad is almost irrelevant. US su
by ClumsyPilot 6y ago
Thos post if based off some serious misunderstandings, two main flaws:
1 - Subs are the ultimate trump card, the rest of the triad is almost irrelevant.
US subs are modern, numerous, and, like all half-decent subs, are basically untrackable. 24/7/365 dozens of them carry hundreds to thousand of nukes, ready to strike even if continental US dissapears. Its the same for other nuclear powers.
2 - Spacex has absolutely no competency in this area, and this personality cult is unhealthy.
- patagurbon 6y agoIIRC there’s only actually 14 SSBNs in the current US fleet. So ~a dozen, although probably only half are on patrol at any one time. That’s still 120 Tridents that could be fired in any response.
- oceanplexian 6y agoIt's very plausible that we would place assets in orbit to intercept ICBMs, similar to the Strategic Defense Initiative. If DoD wanted to develop such a system, there's a good chance it's going up on a SpaceX rocket as a classified payload. Claiming they have no competency is silly since a good portion of their business is National Security Space Launch missions.
- johncolanduoni 6y agoHaving competency launching classified payloads that could possibly be part of a missile defense system requires about as much competency in building missile defense systems as a driver who transports vaccines has in developing vaccines.
- staunch 6y agoYour post would be better without the snark and cult comment...but: 1. The Ohio class subs are quite old and no one knows with any real certainty that they remain untrackable. It's entirely possible they are being tracked through some unknown mechanism like new classes of drones, sensors, info leaks, spies, etc. And your response proves my point: everyone is banking on the Ohio class subs as the trump card. But if they're wrong, we're in a very precarious situation. Hence the need to revamp and expand the other legs of the triad. 2. SpaceX had "no competency" in creating rockets and spaceships until they did. And now they're objectively better than most governments at it. Creating a reentry vehicle that launches on one of their existing platforms doesn't seem implausible, at all. This is probably easier than most of their previous work. Unlike the legacy U.S. defense companies, SpaceX delivers on a budget and time scale that makes choosing them the obvious option. But it probably makes sense to have another company also work on improving the nuclear response.