9 ms·
I would much rather live in a world where there are viable options for responding to a handful of ICBMs that don't involve escalation. Effectively, a credible
by ethbr0 6y ago
I would much rather live in a world where there are viable options for responding to a handful of ICBMs that don't involve escalation.
Effectively, a credible ballistic missile defense + an arms treaty that caps the number of interceptors leaves relative great power parity stable.
But it does eliminate the "rogue state" or "rogue silo" threat. And arguably, makes them less attractive to pursue in the first place, thereby furthering non-proliferation.
If you're Iran, are you going to suffer all the economic pain of breaking sanctions, in return for a non-credible threat?
- tasogare 6y agoHow many aggression wars did Iran starts in modern times? How many the US did? At least three. Your definition and example of a rogue state needs some correction.
- marta_morena_28 6y agoDoes it? What if the US had Iran's military and Iran had US' military? The wars conducted by US are questionable at best and a poor example of how developed nations should behave. However, looking at the worst sides of a developed nation and comparing them to the best sides of a dictator state, isn't quite adding up.
- iaw 6y ago"Rogue state" [0] is actually a defined term that Iran qualifies for because of its efforts to proliferate nuclear weapons. Also, Iran has participated regularly in proxy wars including the one in Yemen with Saudi Arabia [1] so your thesis about aggression wars is a little misleading when they've participated in a proxy civil. Note that recently Israel claimed credit for killing an Al Qaeda leader who was living openly in Iran. I think Iran is too often scapegoated in the Western world but I also want to be realistic about where Iran is really at fault. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rogue_state https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rogue_state [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran%E2%80%93Saudi_Arabia_proxy_conflict https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran%E2%80%93Saudi_Arabia_prox...
- boomboomsubban 6y ago>is actually a defined term that Iran qualifies for because of its efforts to proliferate nuclear weapons. So something it stopped doing over a decade ago makes it a "rogue state?" >Also, Iran has participated regularly in proxy wars including the one in Yemen with Saudi Arabia [1] so your thesis about aggression wars is a little misleading when they've participated in a proxy civil Your source actually doesn't outline any concrete Iranian involvement in Yemen, just some Saudi accusations prior to their invasion. Even then, the US participation alone dwarfs the alleged Iranian involvement. >I think Iran is too often scapegoated in the Western world but I also want to be realistic about where Iran is really at fault. These are the two main issues they're scapegoated for, so this statement is a bit confusing.
- iaw 6y ago> So something it stopped doing over a decade ago makes it a "rogue state?" It was doing it last year after the US unilaterally pulled out of the agreement [0] > Your source actually doesn't outline any concrete Iranian involvement in Yemen, just some Saudi accusations prior to their invasion. Even then, the US participation alone dwarfs the alleged Iranian involvement. Iran never out and out talks about who they support and how. Note that Qasem Soleimeini was killed in Iraq. The point being the Iran meddles in their neighbors affairs. > These are the two main issues they're scapegoated for, so this statement is a bit confusing. No, they're scapegoated as being terrorism funders/stronghold or attackers of "freedom" (whatever that means). When they're called out for actually doing something that the international community frowns upon that's not scapegoating. [0] https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/nov/05/iran-announces-injection-of-uranium-gas-into-1044-centrifuges https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/nov/05/iran-announces...
- fuoqi 6y ago>It was doing it last year after the US unilaterally pulled out of the agreement And who are we should thank for it? Iran clearly sees the difference between North Korea and Libya, and it clearly does not want to be the latter. The US stupid move was just the last droplet. Hopefully with the new administration the situation can be salvaged. >Note that Qasem Soleimeini was killed in Iraq. The point being the Iran meddles in their neighbors affairs. Oh, wow. According to the Iraqi prime minister he was on a diplomatic mission to ease tensions between Iran and Saudi Arabia. He was unlawfully (under both US and international law) assassinated in a clear and blatant violation of the Iraq sovereignty. And compare the Iran "meddling" with the US openly creating military bases in Syria without any authorization from the Syrian government (you think anything you like about it, but it's still an internationally recognized government) and open military support of rebel forces, often closely related to jihadists. Also we have the rejection of the Iraqi parliament′s call to withdraw US troops.
- yyyk 6y agoA half million+ Syrians would have liked to have a word about Iranian behaviour.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- chiph 6y agoI was going to say that the US was limited by the Anti-Ballistic Missile Treaty (the Soviets and the US were limited to two ABM installations each), but the US left the treaty in 2002, because of the threat posed by Iran. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-Ballistic_Missile_Treaty https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-Ballistic_Missile_Treaty
- fuoqi 6y ago>because of the threat posed by Iran. Do you seriously believe this nonsense? The pull was clearly targeted against Russia, in the same way as pull from the INF was targeted mostly against China. Russia even has proposed to share radar data on its south borders with NATO systems, but to no avail.
- throwawayffffas 6y agoAn anti-ballistic missile treaty no longer makes sense, when there were only two or three sides and all of them had enough missiles to overwhelm their adversary, there is no point in even trying to build an ICBM defense program. There is a huge precedent of ICBM defense programs being canceled due to large costs and questionable benefits in the face of a full scale attack from Russia. That is no longer the case, now North Korea has a handful of missiles, with no ballistic missile defense the US would be vulnerable to an attack from North Korea. Sure, such an attack would result in a retaliation. But the duty of the government is not to avenge it's citizens but to protect them in the first place.
- DiogenesKynikos 6y agoThere's a classic clip of Putin breaking out in laughter when an interviewer suggests the missile shield in Eastern Europe is meant to defend against Iran: https://youtu.be/7LyfwHYB8xw https://youtu.be/7LyfwHYB8xw
- Shivetya 6y agoI would be more worried about North Korea. They have already shown their lack of respect for human life by the treatment of their own people and their overt threats to South Korea. They even make propaganda showing attacks against the US and other countries. In a rational world we would not need a military except we are far from living in one. Worse we live in a world where we accept nations like North Korea and worse prop them up all because of the threat they project. This will simply encourage them further. Iran is a threat to its neighbors and a lot of this is from purely factional religious differences. Reducing the world's oil usage could actually make things worse as we end up with a larger humanitarian issue, similar to Venezuela where the economy needs that money
- throwaway894345 6y ago> an arms treaty that caps the number of interceptors leaves relative great power parity stable I don't know much about this topic, but why would you want to cap the number of interceptors? Surely we would want everyone to have lots and lots of interceptors such that nuclear warheads are devalued (not worth stockpiling because their effectiveness is lower)? What's the worst outcome in an arms race on interceptors? Nations spend too much on interceptors?
- DiogenesKynikos 6y agoThe worst case is that one country becomes convinced that it can launch a first strike, and then intercept all the retaliatory strikes.
- throwaway894345 6y agoI guess it would be bad if the interceptors were highly concentrated in a single nation or coalition, but as long as each coalition has plenty (relative to the number of warheads) it shouldn't be a problem. Note that the distribution doesn't even need to be very even--let's say each nation is capped at 100 warheads and Russia has 1000 interceptors and the US has 10000--the US doesn't have much leverage on Russia despite an order of magnitude more interceptors. So as long as all of the interceptors aren't concentrated on one side of an engagement (and it would be very unlikely for this to be the case for any enduring period of time) all is well. And of course, there's the additional deterrent of a globalized economy. Most nuclear countries depend on the global economy and have a strong incentive not to devastate it by way of nuclear warfare. The odds of an isolationist country like NK owning all of the interceptors is pretty low IMO.
- ethbr0 6y agoPossession of num_interceptors > num_counterparty_ICBMs leads to a few undesirable behaviors. - Increased counterparty desire to build more ICBMs - Increased belief in a successful first strike / acceptable response casualties Both of these make the world a more dangerous place. Better to agree on what we're targeting (smaller nuclear states), and preserve the status quo.