3 ms·
> phrasing everything as a question. I wonder if this is generational or cultural? Personally, I dislike trying to interface with a machine using natural lang
by mr_toad 6y ago
> phrasing everything as a question.
I wonder if this is generational or cultural?
Personally, I dislike trying to interface with a machine using natural language, because I know it can’t really understand me, and I’d rather read and interpret the results for myself than have an algorithm pick the “best”.
I actually find speaking to machines (e.g. automated phone systems, Siri etc) using natural language quite embarrassing, as if we were pretending that real life was like Star Trek.
- ddingus 6y agoThis. We do not have machines able to sort meaning out yet, so why bother?
- potatoman22 6y agoFor most information retrieval purposes, Google's NLP algorithms can effectively determine the meaning of your query thanks to BERT
- ddingus 6y agoIn a simple probabilistic sense, sure. Shove enough data at the problem and the easy cases work out. Those are only a small subset of the problem space. Until we address meaning, my statement remains solid. And it can often be easier to treat the tool like what it is rather than figure out how to best pretend it is something it is clearly not.
- zbrozek 6y agoI also hate talking to machines, minus some exceptional circumstances. I find it especially annoying when phone menu systems insist that I talk to them. Some of them don't even respond to mashing zero.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- admax88q 6y agoI think its less about trying to talk to Google, and more about phrasing your search the way somebody would ask it on some random forum. That is often the benefit of asking as a question. Although such queries are habit forming and now google does a decent job understanding the actual question