3 ms·
> Sounds like they blacklisted things likely to clutter up the comment threads and left things unlikely to be used. That’s not really believable given how arbi
by masklinn 6y ago
> Sounds like they blacklisted things likely to clutter up the comment threads and left things unlikely to be used.
That’s not really believable given how arbitrary it is.
> Die faces could lead to weird rolling threads or other things.
As if tiles or playing cards could not be used that way.
> The markup's not great, but too much formatting is distracting.
The problem is that despite having only two directives half of HN’s markup is actively detrimental: because there is no escaping, no inline literals, and the parsing is sub-par, in my experience the “emphasis” directive causes issues more often than it helps. HN’s markup would be significantly improved by removing it entirely.
> I really can't stand when people use those for quotes
Which would be way less likely if HN actually supported quotes.
- grawprog 6y ago>> I really can't stand when people use those for quotes >Which would be way less likely if HN actually supported quotes. But look how well this works ;p. Sorry...couldn't resist. I dunno, I like the 'hackish' nature of it. You're right i'm sure the tiles or playing cards could be used like that too, it may be arbitrary, I don't know. But, those were just some reasons off the top of my head, i'm sure when HN was being programmed a bit more thought went into it, or maybe not, who knows? My main point is, I like the simplicity of it all, sure it could be better, but better doesn't necessarily lead to better quality content. There's a minimum amount of distractions, most users find reasonable ways to communicate the context of the content of their posts and scrolling through most threads tends to be a mostly uniform experience where if users are following a few established conventions, you can follow the flow of things pretty well. It's not perfect, it's not the best, but I feel like it fits the general vibe and nature of the site. It gives HN an identity among all the other news aggregators and forums.
- saagarjha 6y ago> That’s not really believable given how arbitrary it is. No, that's exactly what they did. I asked.