3 ms·
Copyright protects the expression of an idea in a tangible medium. All of these story features are arguably expressions of the same idea, but they're not the sa
by toast0 6y ago
Copyright protects the expression of an idea in a tangible medium. All of these story features are arguably expressions of the same idea, but they're not the same expression, so it's not a copyright issue.
There's an amazing variety of creative products that are based on the same idea; often the better ones aren't the first ones.
- slg 6y agoCopyright protects more than just the specific expression, they also protect collections of ideas. If I publish a novel about a magical wizard who can control things with his mind, flies around the galaxy in a spaceship shaped like an X, carries a laser sword, and battles his cyborg father who wears all black, I bet I would get a call from Disney's lawyers. That is because my work could be deemed substantially similar to Disney's IP even if it is a different expression.
- learnstats2 6y ago> I bet I would get a call from Disney's lawyers. Disney's lawyers are famously litigious. I'm not clear that they would win a case here. (Although they might have success with this HN comment as evidence) The Adventures of Willy the Wizard: Livid Land (1987) has a similar high-level of comparison to Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire (2000), and that case was thrown out.
- slg 6y agoExcept that book didn't have "a similar high-level of comparison to Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire". To quote the judge: "The contrast between the total concept and feel of the works is so stark that any serious comparison of the two strains credulity"[1]. There is a sort of "know it when I see it" nature that is hard to define, but copyright certainly protects works that are substantially similar even if not straight copies, at least in the US. [1] - https://www.bbc.com/news/entertainment-arts-12134288 https://www.bbc.com/news/entertainment-arts-12134288
- learnstats2 6y agoWhat I mean is: "Both Willy [a wizard] and Harry are required to work out the exact nature of the main task of the contest which they both achieve in a bathroom assisted by clues from helpers, in order to discover how to rescue human hostages imprisoned by a community of half-human, half-animal fantasy creatures." is very comparable to your completely hypothetical example above. So, if a paragraph of cherry-picked, high-level description are the only identified similarities, there is no case in copyright law.
- slg 6y agoThe only real similarity between those two stories that isn't easily attributed to a trope of the genre is the fact that scene took place in a bathroom. Everything else is unspecific and common. Also there is a difference when one scene shows similarity rather than the overall arc of the story.