6 ms·
The real competition is no longer Intel. Its AMD. Or if you're just buying Apple because you like them then there is no competition, you buy what they offer. I
by phkahler 6y ago
The real competition is no longer Intel. Its AMD. Or if you're just buying Apple because you like them then there is no competition, you buy what they offer.
I like fanless systems so I'll be watching Apple closely.
- 51Cards 6y agoThen new M1 Pro relies on its fan to prevent throttling so I don't know about their plans to go fanless yet.
- WanderPanda 6y agoMBA is fanless, 12” has been fanless for years (until it was discontinued)
- knolan 6y agoThe Air in the article is fanless.
- kube-system 6y agoRight, and I think some benchmarks I've seen this morning indicate that it throttles during more intensive tasks. The Pro benchmarks better, the only difference being the fan.
- HatchedLake721 6y agoAfter 8 minutes
- jeffbee 6y agoAll CPUs throttle, all of the time. It's been years since anyone shipped a high-performance processor without a closed-loop dynamic thermal control system.
- kube-system 6y agoHaving a throttling mechanism != the throttling mechanism is engaged With enough cooling, you can operate a CPU at full tilt and never engage the throttle.
- jeffbee 6y agoIf your CPU always runs at its steady-state temperature that means it sucks and it leaving performance on the table. A CPU that can run at a steady 3 GHz (or whatever) should be capable of 5+ GHz momentarily given the right initial conditions.
- kube-system 6y agoThermals are not the only factor that limits clock speeds. For instance, gate switching times are also a factor. Although if you're saying the M1's performance "sucks", I can't wait to see the next iteration.
- totalZero 6y agoYou're choosing the argument first and then trying to justify it post hoc. That's the downside of having these conversations in thread format; it's easy to disagree, and tough to acknowledge that the other guy can be right about some things and wrong about others. Sure, the critical path setup and hold time limit clock speeds, but that's not the reason for throttling a chip that can turbo at a higher clock. Even if it were, certain operations with a shorter critical path could run at faster clock even when hot. If thermals weren't the dominant factor, you wouldn't need better cooling to overclock. My perspective (correct me if wrong): Hot semiconductors can damage themselves, and this becomes more important as the lithography shrinks. Binning is designed to identify which silicon can be pushed harder and which is not quite up to the task. I agree with the other guy that if your CPU always runs at its steady-state temperature that means it is leaving performance on the table.
- stu2b50 6y agoBut only after 10+ minutes of full load according to tests. And only after 30 minutes do you get noticeably performance drops (around 20% or so). For developers, for instance, I really doubt you're going to commonly have 30 minutes of full load in your normal workflow.
- vimy 6y agoAccording to one reviewer it takes 8 minutes before it starts to throttle.
- layoutIfNeeded 6y agoHuh? Apple is quite the opposite of fanless... They have literally the most devoted fanbase among computer vendors.
- JeremyNT 6y agoI can't help but chuckle whenever I read these comments on HN about how doomed Intel is. Intel just does this. Every now and then, they get so far ahead that the rest of the market just totally disintegrates, which allows them to screw around and juice up their margins while failing to actually innovate. Their brand is so strong it takes years for it to erode, even when they do suck, and when they have actual competition they've got plenty of cushion to keep selling old designs while they catch up.
- rualca 6y ago> Intel just does this. Every now and then, they get so far ahead that the rest of the market just totally disintegrates, (...) Past performance does not guarantee future results. Keep in mind you're trying to pin magical properties on a brand, and meanwhile people and technologies come and go.
- JeremyNT 6y ago> Keep in mind you're trying to pin magical properties on a brand, and meanwhile people and technologies come and go. Sure, things change! But Intel is huge, and it's got a track record of repeatedly weathering setbacks and missteps only to come back with market dominance. Maybe it's really going to be all about Apple and AMD while Intel plays catch-up for generations to come - I just feel like it's a bit premature to come to that conclusion.
- totalZero 6y agoThe reality of semiconductor tech is that most people are not paying enough attention to understand when a company is doing well and when it's doing poorly. AMD stock was trading in the single digits well after the company was firing on all cylinders. Intel has encountered major bumps in the road since the early days of 10nm, yet research analysts and technologists alike were praising Intel all over the place until recently. I wouldn't call it a KO until Intel 7nm chips come out. At that time, we'll see if this is a comeback story or just another IBM.
- phkahler 6y ago>> I can't help but chuckle whenever I read these comments on HN about how doomed Intel is. I didn't say anything like that. Simply that if you want to compare performance to the best that is currently not Intel. There is a lot of hype around this new apple chip and people claiming it's a performance king, but I seriously doubt that. Even for mobile I'd like to see it compared to AMD APUs.