3 ms·
Therefore I believe it should be a social duty to make everything https so as to ensure that we don’t create something that can be used to harm others. Those w
by userbinator 6y ago
Therefore I believe it should be a social duty to make everything https so as to ensure that we don’t create something that can be used to harm others.
Those who give up freedom for security deserve neither.
- josephcsible 6y agoNobody's saying you should be required by law to use HTTPS. Voting is a social duty too and it's not mandatory.
- wildfire 6y agoThe world would be a better place if voting was mandatory ( like it is in Australia ).
- shadowgovt 6y agoAgree to disagree. I've met enough Americans to believe that if we made voting mandatory, we'd just end up with Optimus Prime at the top of the ticket. You can make an act compulsory on the whole population but you can't legislate duty-of-care upon the whole population.
- kibwen 6y agoVoting should be mandatory but the first listed option for every office should be "I approve of no candidate and think none of them should win" (the disaffected vote), and the second listed option should be "I approve of every candidate and don't care who wins" (the apathetic vote). With our current system it's impossible to tease out how many voters are disaffected vs apathetic vs simply disenfranchised (in the above scheme, those who don't make it to the polls at all), which makes it impossible to confirm or deny that any candidate has the mandate of the people.
- a1369209993 6y agoTechnically those options are trivial with a non-defective system like approval voting, but assuming you're stuck with first-past-the-post, that's pretty much correct.
- kibwen 6y agoNot quite, even with normal approval voting there's no way to distinguish between voters who want to say "all these options are undesirable and everything is broken" and those who want to say "life is good, I'm cool with whoever" and those whose votes get lost or obstructed. The reason why the notion of a "protest vote" is so pointless under our current system is specifically due to the indistinguishability of the first from the latter ("people didn't stay home because they didn't like the candidates, they stayed home because they're so content!"). Additionally without mandatory voting it's difficult to determine where and how voter disenfranchisement is happening, but at the same time it would be unethical to force someone to cast a vote without giving them the option to voice discontent with the options.
- a1369209993 6y agoWhat definition of "approval voting" are you using? I'm talking about a ballot where each candidate is marked "approve" or "reject". With that system, "all these options are undesirable and everything is broken" is reject-all, while "life is good, I'm cool with whoever" is approve-all (and lost or obstructed is obviously no ballot at all; there's not much you can do about that).
- BeefySwain 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compulsory_voting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compulsory_voting
- josephcsible 6y agoIn the United States, it's considered a social duty but isn't mandatory.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- burkaman 6y agoWhat freedom do I give up by adding HTTPS to my website?
- shadowgovt 6y agoThat quote is often taken badly out of context. Benjamin Franklin, to the legislature of Pennsylvania, on the topic of basically letting the Penn family buy their way out of paying taxes indefinitely by providing enough hired mercenaries to protect the colony's frontier during the French and Indian war. The freedom he was talking about was a legislature's freedom to govern. The temporary security he was talking about was hired guns. And none of it applies to the question of the tragedy of the commons that is "HTTP protocol is default embarrassingly insecure." Indeed, if I were to torture the quote enough to make it fit, it looks more like "Those who would give up essential Liberty (Mozilla, in this case, to design the user agent the way they think best benefits their users and the World Wide Web as a whole) to purchase a little temporary Safety (... of their user count by delaying inconveniencing users in the corner cases where HTTPS can't be used), deserve neither Liberty nor Safety." But it barely fits.