3 ms·
Well I have done this in the past to people I know who say they have "nothing to hide" and the answer they give is super simple - "I'm happy to provide all of t
by gambiting 6y ago
Well I have done this in the past to people I know who say they have "nothing to hide" and the answer they give is super simple - "I'm happy to provide all of the above and more to law enforcement agencies at any point. I don't have any problem with authority and I don't understand why you do.".
You can then explain that the data does get misused, but they always just say that it won't happen to them or if they do get in a hairy situation they will always explain themselves since after all they have nothing to hide.
- garbagetime 6y agoThe (unlikely) fact the person has done nothing wrong seems to be an irrelevancy: an immoral government will target per anyway. See model-citizen Uyghurs becoming targeted by the Chinese government just for being Uyghurs.
- gambiting 6y agoWell the example I like to give is that pre WW2 many countries gathered completely normal census data, but of course during WW2 Nazis used it to find out exactly where Jews lived. So the data was collected with perfectly good intentions and it was then used to kill people. To which of course all I hear is "Well yes, but that's not going to happen to the UK, so I don't think it's important"
- garbagetime 6y agoOn the one hand antisemitism is definitely a massive, deep issue in the Labour party. On the other hand there's no way Jews could be systematically targeted in the future.
- codazoda 6y agoI'm starting to create a list of abuses that have happened to people who have "nothing to hide". Are there any examples from the community here?
- alpaca128 6y agoAsk them if they'd also be fine with hackers potentially leaking all their account data to the public. There are enough real-life examples, like the Equifax debacle or that "dating" site where multiple people committed suicide when their online identities got leaked. The only way to guarantee personal data cannot be abused by anyone, authority or not, is when those data don't exist at all. We know that governments are too incompetent to follow best practices in security, we know that this kind of power gets abused with barely any limits because there's no accountability(e.g. when a prominent German singer did a concert police officers made 83 lookups of her data in the police database just in that single night. Nothing ever came out of it even though the police had to admit those numbers aren't possible without abuse).
- SuoDuanDao 6y agoI suspect that to a great degree, people who say they have nothing to hid do have something to hide, but are trying to bluster their way out of closer scrutiny. The Ashley Madison thing is an excellent example, if anyone would commit suicide over having details of that nature leaked they certainly wouldn't admit to having anything of the sort on their conscience when discussing the matter with friends or family. It's a bit of a tricky situation because as has been noted upthread, the best practical way to maintain privacy is to simulate the ambient data noise. So in a sense, loudly proclaiming one has nothing to hide is the best strategy for keeping one's own privacy secure, but at the expense of everyone else's. I don't get into these conversations much, but if I do perhaps I should try out the response: "I don't have anything to hide either, but I know a lot of my fellow citizens value their privacy. So I'm willing to advocate for it even though I know it will lead to more scrutiny on myself. Anyone who's afraid of that extra scrutiny is suspect! What are you really hiding!?"
- Nasrudith 6y agoThe best retort is "You don't get to decide that - your persecutor does and you have no way of knowing what their twisted ideology will find 'wrong' with your past actions."
- gambiting 6y agoTo which again, the answer is "I trust the authority and I trust the system". I've heard this too many times, ultimately the conversation ends with "but I trust the police and I trust the courts, so I really don't care"
- livueta 6y agoThis reminds me of an old /g/ post: --- The thing people don't realize about the 'nothing to hide' mantra is that it only makes sense if someone looks at your whole life. If you really did have someone examining everything you ever did, watching a playback of your entire life, through your eyes - and this was the only form that anyone would get your data in, by watching everything - then yeah, you probably wouldn't need to hide anything. That person would see everything you do, and understand you pretty well by the end of it. All the things you did, even the seemingly weird things, would make sense in context. They'd sympathize with you. But that isn't what happens. What does happen is huge amounts of data are recorded, but only little pieces are looked at at a time. And suddenly you do have something to hide, because the people looking at the data on you won't have the full story, and will therefore jump to conclusions based on what they have - and because you won't know when and where this is happening, and what specifically they're looking at, you won't be able to set them straight. Suddenly your every action has to look innocent on its own, you can't do anything that is justifiable given prior events or knowledge. Your wife has been treating you like shit for months, and finally you snap and yell at her? If they only see the end of it then you look like the bad guy. You're researching bombs because you're interested in the historical development of technology, including explosive technology? Tough shit, you don't get to explain that, to them it will just look like you're a big bad terrorist wanting to blow up the government. You might say that they will have all your information so they can fact-check. This is wrong, they have neither the incentive or the time to trawl through your whole life working out your motivations for everything. It's easiest to just jump to conclusions. And employers will look at this and make judgments on you - without you having any idea what they're seeing and what they're concluding from it. In public, people carefully monitor their behavior so they appear normal to anyone who only sees them for a second. They're only willing to show their weirder sides to people who know them, who won't make big judgments on them based on minor quirks. With total surveillance, everyone will be in public, all the time. --- I wonder how much a version of the fundamental attribution error is responsible for "nothing to hide" kind of thinking.
- fl0wenol 6y agoAmplifying this because nail->head. Also adding to the FAE angle, we have to consider what a potentially "bad" action looks like not just outside of context, but in aggregate, because in these systems you're probably looking for outliers, unusual sentiment, not just key terms. This has a chilling effect on any extra-normal behavior. If it was implicit that context leading up to and afterwards were required to interpret the outlier, one would see it's probably not an outlier after all, but that requires a lot of people's time and potentially your involvement. Even if that context could be supplied with tons of surveillance and people/AI, I'd wager people would rather not be hauled in front of the internet police to explain every non-obvious, out-of-the-ordinary thing they directly or indirectly associated with.
- goatinaboat 6y agoif they do get in a hairy situation they will always explain themselves since after all they have nothing to hide Every middle class person thinks that but what they don't understand is that cops spend their entire lives being lied to, every day, nearly everyone they speak to who isn't a fellow cop is lying to them. So that you are lying is their default position. They're going to go with whatever it says on their screen or whatever another cop told them, 100% of the time.