3 ms·
Suppose that instead the device did work by analysing the user's brain state and predicts whether they will press the button or not. The device can also take in
by simonh 6y ago
Suppose that instead the device did work by analysing the user's brain state and predicts whether they will press the button or not. The device can also take into account the influence of the light flashing, or not, on the user's decision because it has full information about the state of the universe and the laws of physics. What happens then? Please think about it before reading my solution below, I'd be interested to see what independent conclusions other people come to.
I suspect that in that case, the device wouldn't work reliably. There's no way for it to influence the person's decision to press the button or not simply by choosing to illuminate the light or not even with full information. That's simply not a powerful enough input into the person's decision making process, even if that decision making process is perfectly deterministic and we ignore things like quantum indeterminacy. However I don't know how to prove or test that logically.