5 ms·

I can say that while staying with locals I never registered or being asked to. And it went like this for a couple of months. Not only with Chinese, but also exp

by easyKL 6y ago

I can say that while staying with locals I never registered or being asked to. And it went like this for a couple of months. Not only with Chinese, but also expats. I mainly got my accomodation though CouchSurfing (I wasn't aware of BeWelcome nor TrustRoots back then) The hosts seemed to have guests very often and we were never asked to pretend to be friends from home or anything. This happened not only in the main cities, also in some prefecture-level cities. It happened on a tourist visa, back in 2015

busterarm 6y ago
Yes, many people do in fact break the law and get away with it. This should not be surprising.
- wolco2 6y ago
  If it is common then why did you say this was dangerous?
  - Torn 6y ago
    Chinese police are not known for a lax attitude to rule breaking when it comes to foreigners
    - CURLY3Y 6y ago
      Anecdotal experiences incoming: I am moderately involved with various sinology students from Europe. And have traveled to China personally. Personally I stayed at various AirBnBs within China and registered at the police in Bejing and Shanghai. The host provided a signed letter confirming where we are staying. With that letter I headed to a local police station where I gave the letter and had to fill out a form with basic personal details and address of where I was staying. In return I got a stamped letter confirming my stay. Anecdotes from others: People who have registered late for various reasons (finding apartment, inconvenient arrival combined with work, etc) I have as of yet not heard anything experience other than the police saying please register on time next time and still got their stamped confirmation of stay. One standout story however is someone who looked up a recent political dissident via Baidu and got a visit from the police, nothing really exceptional happened except he got visited at his apartment got told off, had to sign a letter confirming the visit and infraction. The person in question has been back to china multiple times since.
      - Razengan 6y ago
        > someone who looked up a recent political dissident via Baidu and got a visit from the police ......How is anyone okay with this..
      - bosie 6y ago
        > had to sign a letter confirming the visit and infraction. sorry, what infraction?
        TimTheTinker 6y ago
        Looking up a political dissident. That's apparently illegal in China. (It is a communist nation where disagreeing with the government is tantamount to treason and is treated as such.)
    - blablablub 6y ago
      Chinese police are known to shy away from any work that falls away from what they are normally doing. Registering a foreigner in a small town is a once in a lifetime experience for them, so many things can go wrong, so they wont do it.
powerapple 6y ago
The problem will only arise when you happen to be a criminal and your friend will be in trouble. If nothing happens, no one is going to check the record.

by easyKL 6y ago

busterarm 6y ago

Yes, many people do in fact break the law and get away with it. This should not be surprising.

wolco2 6y ago
If it is common then why did you say this was dangerous?
- Torn 6y ago
  Chinese police are not known for a lax attitude to rule breaking when it comes to foreigners
  - CURLY3Y 6y ago
    Anecdotal experiences incoming: I am moderately involved with various sinology students from Europe. And have traveled to China personally. Personally I stayed at various AirBnBs within China and registered at the police in Bejing and Shanghai. The host provided a signed letter confirming where we are staying. With that letter I headed to a local police station where I gave the letter and had to fill out a form with basic personal details and address of where I was staying. In return I got a stamped letter confirming my stay. Anecdotes from others: People who have registered late for various reasons (finding apartment, inconvenient arrival combined with work, etc) I have as of yet not heard anything experience other than the police saying please register on time next time and still got their stamped confirmation of stay. One standout story however is someone who looked up a recent political dissident via Baidu and got a visit from the police, nothing really exceptional happened except he got visited at his apartment got told off, had to sign a letter confirming the visit and infraction. The person in question has been back to china multiple times since.
    - Razengan 6y ago
      > someone who looked up a recent political dissident via Baidu and got a visit from the police ......How is anyone okay with this..
    - bosie 6y ago
      > had to sign a letter confirming the visit and infraction. sorry, what infraction?
      - TimTheTinker 6y ago
        Looking up a political dissident. That's apparently illegal in China. (It is a communist nation where disagreeing with the government is tantamount to treason and is treated as such.)
  - blablablub 6y ago
    Chinese police are known to shy away from any work that falls away from what they are normally doing. Registering a foreigner in a small town is a once in a lifetime experience for them, so many things can go wrong, so they wont do it.

powerapple 6y ago

The problem will only arise when you happen to be a criminal and your friend will be in trouble. If nothing happens, no one is going to check the record.