5 ms·
America desperately needs a national internal affairs department with an entirely separate reporting line whose boss answers directly to the president (or at le
by pydry 6y ago
America desperately needs a national internal affairs department with an entirely separate reporting line whose boss answers directly to the president (or at least state governors).
They could purchase, maintain the body cameras, collect and handle the footage and be trusted.
If Biden is looking to score some points this would be a good way.
- bigbubba 6y agoIsn't that one of the roles the FBI has?
- pydry 6y agoAs far as i know it's more or less handled by police forces themselves with predictable results.
- bigbubba 6y agoIt's my understanding that the FBI is meant to handle matters of state or local government corruption, which I would think includes police departments that circle their wagons and protecting criminal cops. Probably they need to be doing a better job of it, but I believe they're meant to be (among other things) the organization you describe above. I'm not really familiar with the details, but it's my understanding the Seattle PD are under some sort of probation system with the DOJ, which I'm guessing the FBI was involved with. So I think this sort of thing does happen, though I guess not enough.
- pdonis 6y ago> the FBI is meant to handle matters of state or local government corruption They have a certain amount of ability to do that if the state or local government is violating Federal law. But they do not have general oversight or police powers, since the Federal government as a whole does not. Nor is it supposed to.
- bigbubba 6y agoWouldn't local cops violating people's constitutional rights put them at odds with federal law?
- tristor 6y agoYes, and as a general rule when cases are brought they are under the auspices of a federal civil rights violation. These are very difficult cases to prosecute though, so I think the FBI overfocuses on lower hanging fruit unless there's a political motivation from the top to drive this.
- pdonis 6y agoYes, but that just means prosecuting individual cases. That is very different from trying to make systemic changes in the way local cops operate; those kinds of changes must be made by local governments, and are the kind of changes local citizens should be demanding, and should be voting local governments out of office for not making.
- kbenson 6y agoI'm pretty sure trying to pass something like that would very quickly devolve into an argument about states rights. Probably rightly so, as even though oversight would be good, a Federal agency to do so might be problematic for many reasons.
- ethbr0 6y agoPretty much every state has their own, state-level investigation bureau [0]. Automatically transferring footage to an internal affairs department there would distance it from the actual department, while preserving state control. Aside from activating / deactivating the camera (with clear guidelines and penalties for doing / not doing so), and connecting it to a network at the end of a shift, it should be a black box. None of the IT functions should run out of the same police force. Consequently, this also protects officers in the case of equipment failure: timestamp the activation / deactivation signals in a separate log file. If the footage isn't there, but they activated, then it's no longer their reputation on the line, because they had no involvement in the chain of custody. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_bureau_of_investigation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_bureau_of_investigation
- kbenson 6y agoYeah, a state department side-steps a lot of those problems (but also possibly lets states ignore it). A federal law requiring police interactions to be recorded and submitted to a state entity and requiring it be stored for a certain period would probably suffice. Then the FBI or whoever investigated an issue Federally (if it got to that) could subpoena it, since it's supposed to exist, and be handled by the state. I agree it should be a black box. Rule #1 for accountability is that you don't rely on the entity that's being examined to give absolutely correct info. Whether that's debugging a process or reviewing an organization, outside instrumentation is essential.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- msla 6y agoThat would be contrary to the whole spirit of Federalism. It would be like every EU country having a separate department of internal affairs which reports directly to Brussels, except, perhaps, even more politically inflammatory. I'm not saying I necessarily disagree with you, just noting that there's a big wall in the path of implementing the concept.
- triceratops 6y agoGP said internal affairs could report to state governors.
- msla 6y agoI think they edited their post.
- pjc50 6y agoThe US is a single country with a single military.
- ethbr0 6y ago> The US is a single country with a single military. Not... entirely accurate. Many states possess their own military forces [0], and state National Guard units are dual-chained to both state and national military leadership [1] (in different scenarios). [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_defense_force#Active_state_defense_forces https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_defense_force#Active_sta... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_National_Guard#National_Guard_active_duty_character https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_National_Guard#N...
- sokoloff 6y agoThat big wall being the tenth amendment to the Constitution.
- bird_monster 6y ago> If Biden is looking to score some points this would be a good way. If only a significant % of america didn't refuse to acknowledge police abuse of power was a big deal (or even happening)
- pdonis 6y agoNo. This is not a national government problem. This is a local government problem. The solution is for citizens of those cities and counties to hold their local governments accountable and vote them out of office if they don't fix the problem. The last thing we need is more big government, one-size-fits-none policies dictated from above. We need more local people solving their own local problems. It would also help if police were not tasked with enforcing a litany of nanny state laws that shouldn't even be on the books to begin with. Any cop that wants to mess with a citizen can always find some excuse; with all the laws we have, all of us are violating some law every day.
- bfuclusion 6y agoI don't think it can be broken down so simply. It's clear that the constitution has provisions specifically covering this (ex: 4th amendment), so the Federal courts at least have an interest in seeing the cases. As the highest law in the land, it's also pretty clear the 14th gives SOME federal oversight of violations of citizen's rights.
- pydry 6y agoThis is absolutely a national problem. Moreover corrupt cops thrive because of close knit relationships between local DAs, local law enforcement, local judges and local politicians. A national wrecking ball is needed to break these toxic corrupt relationships and a strong, national institution is needed to create the institutional inertia against systemic police corruption from arising again. You can't vote corruption out of office. It has to be rooted out from outside. Even the cleanest politicians cannot operate from within a corrupt system.
- Clubber 6y agoIt's a national problem in the sense that it happens all over the nation and isn't limited to a particular department. It's a state and local problem in the sense that legally, the states and local governments have jurisdiction over their police force. The US is a union of states. Although we have a pretty massive and powerful federal government, many things are the responsibility of the states and the federal government has limited ability to intervene. Using the FBI is one of the avenues I believe though.
- eigenman 6y agoMost police departments have internal affairs departments, but these are largely toothless. I would not expect a national organization to perform much better. The incentives simply are not aligned: it is easy to see a politician leaning on the department saying "this will make me look bad, make it go away." I think what would be more powerful would be to empower citizens to bring criminal cases against police offers acting in their official capacity. Then at least we could be assured that the prosecutors are motivated to win the case for their clients.
- pydry 6y agoLocal internal affairs departments don't work because your career is dependent upon this corrupt judge, DA, cop in your area with whom you will work again. You're incentivized not to look too closely because your career is on the line. Plenty of good cops who have uncovered corruption have been personally targeted this way. In a national department? You get to the top by putting dirty cops in jail. Your boss's boss does not need to maintain an good relationship with a judge in Georgia. They win in their career by putting more dirty cops in jail. The more national and centralized and separate from the rest of the police a department like this is the more ruthless it can be.
- syshum 6y agoI would agree with State level IA body operating under the AG of the state. I reject the idea that all problems have a national solutions, which this seems to be a part of. Federalism is good, and we should not continue the path of destruction of our federalist society
- dragonwriter 6y ago> America desperately needs a national internal affairs department ith an entirely separate reporting line whose boss answers directly to the president (or at least state governors). The closest thing (and its fairly close, though it doesn't answer to the states or the President directly) is the US Department of Justice, particularly the Special Litigation Section of the Civil Rights Division, which addresses "1) the rights of people in state or local institutions, including: jails, prisons, juvenile detention facilities, and health care facilities for persons with disabilities; 2) the rights of individuals with disabilities to receive services in their communities, rather than in institutions; 3) the rights of people who interact with state or local police or sheriffs' departments; 4) the rights of youth involved in the juvenile justice system; 5) the rights of people to have safe access to reproductive health care clinics; and 6) the rights of people to practice their religion while confined to state and local institutions." [0] But weakening oversight of local law enforcement by DoJ was a major early priority of the current Administration, so it hasn't been particularly active in the particular role you are concerned with for the last few years. > If Biden is looking to score some points this would be a good way. I can't really imagine a Biden Administration not ramping activity regarding law enforcement oversight back up. [0] https://www.justice.gov/crt/special-litigation-section https://www.justice.gov/crt/special-litigation-section