8 ms·
Yes, she did, but I can't say that it merits 6 months in jail. Charging $193,000 for what someone here estimated was about 90GB of data is, itself, highway rob
by Natsu 16y ago
Yes, she did, but I can't say that it merits 6 months in jail.
Charging $193,000 for what someone here estimated was about 90GB of data is, itself, highway robbery. But that's Telstra's fault, not the power company's.
- tptacek 16y agoIt might be highway robbery in the service model of iPhones downloading movies. That doesn't make it highway robbery in the context of access cards provisioned within the requirements and fee structure of a utility smart meter deployment. It does not all add up to the same thing.
- georgieporgie 16y agoYou're right, it probably adds up to less. A utility company's meter likely doesn't demand the low latency that an iPhone user does. So, it's probably not even worth $80.
- usedtolurk 16y ago90GB of data was stolen - nobody is defending that. Some of us have trouble believing that 90GB of data is actually worth the $193,000 as determined by the Telstra contract. The actual "damage" seems pretty small when compared to crimes which carry similar sentences. If Telstra had a fairer billing system, then a more appropriate sentence would have been more likely.
- tungwaiyip 16y agoI agree. This is robbery! Completely anti-consumer! No sensible consumer or business could have pay this kind of service charge. Telstra could have easily block access to any individual with excessive network activity. The judge should reject this bill and ask arbitrator to come up with reasonable payment plan. Automatically upgrade her to unlimited plan and then add a small penalty should be a reasonable resolution. Law maker should ban telco from excessive charge, say more than $1000 a month, unless authorized by the customer.
- tptacek 16y agoBasically what you're saying is that Telstra should come up with a product to support people who steal the SIM cards out of utility smart meters.
- tungwaiyip 16y agoI say is telecom should not be allow to gouge consumers. They should not charge consumer an amount that is clearly not agreed upon. If you have misconfigured an app on your phone and it run up $10,000 network charge in month. Will you hand over your $10,000 to the phone company? Do you think this is a fair charge? Cap the telco off how much they can charge unless authorized. I think this is most fair for both party. Telco can cut off access, but no to gouge consumer.
- tptacek 16y agoThe person who rips the SIM card out of their smart meter and uses to download stuff off the Internet isn't a consumer.
- tungwaiyip 16y agotptacek, in the scenario that I've construct, if you misconfigured an app that result in an astronomical bill, we you pay it without contest? Will you do it if you have to sell your house to pay off the phone company?
- Natsu 16y agoIndeed. They're talking about informing the power company that someone is misusing one of their SIMs. You know, so that they can discover the theft a bit faster than they did in this case, where it took them from November 19, 2009 until February 9, 2010. A lot less would have been stolen from the power company were that the case.
- Natsu 16y agoThis sort of thing also happens to people who do not steal SIM cards. It is all too common, sadly: http://abclocal.go.com/wjrt/story?section=news/bizarre&id=7169279 http://abclocal.go.com/wjrt/story?section=news/bizarre&i... $22,000 bill because son's data use wasn't covered in family cell phone plan. http://www.switched.com/2007/12/14/man-gets-slapped-with-85-000-cell-phone-bill/ http://www.switched.com/2007/12/14/man-gets-slapped-with-85-... $85,000 phone bill. "It turns out that he was being charged on a per-kilobyte basis because his unlimited browsing plan didn't cover using the phone as a modem. As a "goodwill" gesture, Bell Mobility has dropped the bill to measly $3,243." Finally, here's one from Telstra: http://www.blackberryforums.com.au/forums/general-bis-discussion/1014-huge-phone-bill.html http://www.blackberryforums.com.au/forums/general-bis-discus... "I have recently signed my BB 8800 up on a Telstra $39.95/mth plan which I understood was for unlimited email and internet browsing. I got the shock of my life when I checked my data usage online and saw a bill for $250+ after only a couple of days. On examining further I note that I have not been charged for blackberry.net connections but heavily charged for wap.telstra."
- stoney 16y agoMaybe highway robbery, but pretty standard in Australia - mobile phones are expensive here. As someone pointed out in another comment, Telstra's standard price for off plan data is $2/Mb (for a consumer mobile, not a b2b contract which is presumably what the power company had). For 90Gb of data that works out at $180,000, so pretty consistent with the reported cost.
- Natsu 16y agoIndeed. In spite of living on roughly the other side of the planet from them, I've heard many complaints about Telstra.