7 ms·
The big issue with this design is that it would be necessary to change the curvature as the focal length changes. If they can get that working reliably, it woul
by sudosysgen 6y ago
The big issue with this design is that it would be necessary to change the curvature as the focal length changes. If they can get that working reliably, it would be an absolute game changer - lenses would get much cheaper, much lighter, and of higher quality too.
- giuliomagnifico 6y agoMaybe they’re developing a fixed lens camera like the Leica Q or the old (defunct) R1XR.
- sudosysgen 6y agoMaybe! A fixed lens médium format caméra would be very... Interesting to the very least.
- jetrink 6y agoIt was not unheard-of back in the film days. The cameras, like the Fuji GW690, were not exactly small, but you could carry them around on a neck-strap and use them without a tripod. 1. http://camera-wiki.org/wiki/Fujica_GW690 http://camera-wiki.org/wiki/Fujica_GW690
- Exmoor 6y agoTrue, but the inherent costs of a medium format sensor (not even taking into account the likely extra costs of a curved sensor) mean that the bare minimum you could sell this fixed-lens camera for would be several thousand dollars. I just don't see a lot of photographers being willing to drop that much money on a camera that they can never expand the capabilities of.
- jeswin 6y agoThe Leica Q2 sells for $5000 dollars - I'm guessing it's (or was until Covid hit) selling decently. There would be many who'd prefer a light medium format with fixed lens instead of the Q2 if it's under 7K or 8K. It'll blow the Q2 out of the water.
- giuliomagnifico 6y agoLeica Q is one of the best selling camera for Leica, infact they raised the price 3/4 years ago. Also the Q2 had a 200€ price increase in EU (https://www.macfilos.com/2019/08/01/leica-q2-price-rises-in-germany/ https://www.macfilos.com/2019/08/01/leica-q2-price-rises-in-...). Leica has already a medium format camera (S) with interchangeable lenses, its super expansive but a medium format Leica with fixed lens for (example) 9000$ I think would sell really a lot. Also a Sony medium format for 7/8000€ would sell a lot (more than Leica surely). We’ll see...
- achamayou 6y agoA GS645w isn’t much larger than a modern 35mm digital, and is certainly lighter.
- brudgers 6y agoQuite a lot of medium format cameras were fixed lens. Pretty much all the TLR’s (except some Mamiya’s). All the folders (to a first approximation), the Brownies, and even today all those Holgas.
- petepete 6y agoIs it defunct? It's still listed on their website. https://www.sony.co.uk/electronics/cyber-shot-compact-cameras/dsc-rx1-rx1r https://www.sony.co.uk/electronics/cyber-shot-compact-camera...
- giuliomagnifico 6y agoMaybe Sony is still salling it but was coming out 4/5 years ago without updates. I don’t know who want to buy it instead an A7
- porphyra 6y agoIt still has unparalleled small size. The a7C is a nice alternative but it's not 42 megapixels. And there are not many compact 35mm lenses with good image quality, and the compact ones tend to be f/2.8 rather than f/2.
- robin_reala 6y agoI don’t get that. The existing flat sensors don’t change curvature as focal length changes?
- sudosysgen 6y agoThat's because current lenses correct field curvature so that the image plane is flat. This takes extra glass and can degrade image quality. If you could have a sensor with the correct curvature for the focal length of the lens, you don't need to correct field curvature anymore, which means that you need less glass and have higher quality. If you have the wrong curvature for the focal length, some field correction will still be required, which defeats the advantage. In the real world, it's even more than just focal length that changes the required curvature.
- foo_barrio 6y agoWill it defeat the advantage or lessen it? For example, some people still need glasses after LASIK but still opt for it since they get end up with needing weaker lenses.
- giuliomagnifico 6y agoNo, absolutely. The sensor is flat and when you change the focal length, the sensor gets the same “light/illumination”. That is the plus of a curved sensor: better image/photo at the border of the frame because there is always the same distance between the lens and the sensor.
- brudgers 6y agoLenses never get cheaper. Look at micro four thirds. At the high end they don’t get lighter except for really long wide lenses. That’s because they got heavier when autofocus was added. The original manual focus Nikon 500mm f4 “only” weighs 3kg. It’s lighter than the current $12k model which shed about 2.4kg since the first autofocus version. Plastic is easiest way to make a lens lighter and high end buyers are adverse to plastic. People buy lenses by the kilogram so to speak.
- sudosysgen 6y agoThat is true. That being said, there is a renaissance in third party lenses, and their quality as well as their autofocus performance is increasing, fast. If you are willing to buy third party, maybe even Chinese lenses, they are getting cheaper. If we ever get a true variable curvature sensor, designing lenses will get so much easier and cheaper that I can see even more third party lenses of even higher quality, at an even *lower price. In any case, I agree with the point about plastic lenses.
- perardi 6y agoThat being said, there is a renaissance in third party lenses, and their quality as well as their autofocus performance is increasing, fast. While I agree with you, the third-party lenses that have gotten notably better are Sigma’s, which are no longer cheaper, and are also just big ol’ chonkers now. https://www.dpreview.com/products/Sigma/lenses/sigma_85_1p4_dg_hsm_a/overview https://www.dpreview.com/products/Sigma/lenses/sigma_85_1p4_...
- sudosysgen 6y agoAh, I'm not really thinking of Sigma, I'm talking of Neewer, Viltrox, Mitakon, and in some respects Tamron, and so on. They are making very good primes nowadays, and Viltrox even makes good AF primes now. What's missing is even more AF and zoom.
- brudgers 6y agoThird party medium format system lenses are not something I see when browsing. Though I would not be stunned to come across a Vmount product. I would attribute most of it to market size and adapters for the mirrorless systems and maybe the availability of used 645 lenses. 35mm is a whole different scale of market with entirely different buyers. The entry point cost to medium format is more than the 99th percentile of 35mm like systems.