6 ms·
I get that everyone needs money and all dollars are green even if you have to sell your soul to get them but these sorts of pro-tourism "look how quaint this lo
by throwaway0a5e 6y ago
I get that everyone needs money and all dollars are green even if you have to sell your soul to get them but these sorts of pro-tourism "look how quaint this local boutique industry is" articles really rub me the wrong way.
- celim307 6y agoI didn’t get many marketing vibes from this. Sounded like a young writer experiencing something new
- colordrops 6y agoImagine making money as a struggling journalist writing about an industry that supplies to high-end restaurants. The gall.
- zucked 6y agoQuite a jaded view of the world. This is more that just a boutique industry - this is how a lot of our food makes it to our tables; the part that hasn't been relentlessly mechanized, automated, and conglomerated, anyways. Is it a bit romanticized? Perhaps. But, there are thousands of these small-scale "boutique" operations around the country in all sorts of industries. How quickly we've forgotten that this is how it used to be done.
- throwaway0a5e 6y ago>Quite a jaded view of the world. I grew up in one of these sorts of tourism places. Just because some people make a living doing Actual Things(TM) doesn't mean that having a large portion of the economy be tourism related does not have negative effects for pretty much everyone. >this is how a lot of our food makes it to our tables; And someone dicking around fixing heavy equipment in the mud is how the table became your table but you don't see people romanticizing the timber industry because for the most part it isn't associated with tourism the way waterfront communities (and by extension, their industries) are. The fishing industry exists as much to give the tourists something to look at so the captains' wives/friends/relatives can run successful restaurants and bars (and fish the tourists wallets) as it does to pull edible animals out of the water. On a community level this is all pretty soul crushing because your existence is predicated on your ability to basically put on a show for others (i.e. look quaint) but pretend that you're just this quaint naturally.
- pm90 6y ago> On a community level this is all pretty soul crushing because your existence is predicated on your ability to basically put on a show for others (i.e. look quaint). So, like all of Hollywood? : ) It seems like in your book, “putting on a show for others” is somehow a distasteful means of living. However, many people enjoy this lifestyle. Reinventing something as basic as fishing into an “experience” for tourists, most of who are likely city dwellers who would never get to experience this, seems like a win win to me, and honestly something we could get other industries involved in. You mention the timber industry... if there were places that would allow me to cut down trees with a chainsaw, I would actually be interested in that! As more of human society urbanizes, we’re going to see a lot more demand for these “experiences”.
- zucked 6y agoI had a long response typed out, but you said it better than I could. I think humans have a desire to work with their hands and see the fruits of those labor. As more and more of us push paper and sling 1's and 0's, we're losing that connection and seeing the outcome in things like "Experience" tourism and the romanticizing of hard work. Look at what is popular on Youtube - 'mustie1' fixes junk with his hands in 30 minute videos for nearly 500k subscribers. 'Primitive Technology' replicate(d) societal development for 10.3M subscribers. Nobody is arguing that this work is hard. Sorry if the "theatre" of it bothers you, but I think it's a net societal benefit to help reconnect people back to "artisan" and "boutique" ways of living. We still need those people - think of tourism as a recruiting tool.
- MisterTea 6y agoBecause it's akin to slum tourism. The article appears to be written by a well to do author who takes on a hard blue collar job for a very short period of time. They then write about the unique and whimsical experience. We get treated to a cozy story about picturesque fishing villages as viewed through rose colored glasses. Meanwhile the work is hard, dirty and dangerous for the people who do this for a living in order to survive day to day. The author gets to go back to their well to do life on a family owned island while the fishermen continue to toil at sea.
- molsongolden 6y agoThe slum tourism point is a good one to keep in mind but you’re a little unfair to the fishermen here. There are many fishermen who choose the life because it’s what they love. They aren’t toiling away in the mines to put a scrap of bread on the table—they’re out on the water, working in their community, captaining their own boat and doing work that is strenuous but fulfilling.
- SloopJon 6y agoIndeed, the author writes of the captain she worked for: > Originally from Connecticut, she worked one summer on a whale-watching boat in Bar Harbor, saw the lobstermen, and thought: I want to do that, that looks real.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoThe unique and whimsical experiences seem to be a feature for her boat captain too, so that seems a little unfair. And yes, the author does get to go back to her "well to do life", but she does not downplay the hardness, dirt or danger of this work. Your position seems to suggest that you can't write about the sorts of things the author wanted to write about - the intersections between loneliness, isolation, community, friendship and work - unless you're not well-to-do and spend years or even a lifetime in a job. I reject that perspective.
- fallingfrog 6y agoNo, she said it was a populated island, I’ll bet it was Peak’s. Lots of people live there, lots of lobster fishermen, real estate is a bit expensive but not California expensive and they have a little school house.