3 ms·
> it'd be pointless to run a challenge trial full of low-risk individuals. This is binary all-or-nothing thinking. It considers 90% the same as 0%, since both
by BurningFrog 6y ago
> it'd be pointless to run a challenge trial full of low-risk individuals.
This is binary all-or-nothing thinking. It considers 90% the same as 0%, since both are not 100%.
Testing on healthy young people you learn how a normal immune system reacts to a vaccine candidate. High risk groups mostly have similar immune systems.
Even if somehow you could only vaccinate everyone under 60, that would do enormous good stopping the spread.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- firethief 6y ago> This is binary all-or-nothing thinking. It considers 90% the same as 0%, since both are not 100%. Thinking is not just "binary or not"; there are degrees. If exposing that group of people would be 90% pointless, it's not much less out of the question than if it were 100% pointless.
- BurningFrog 6y agoI like your recursive "degrees of binarity" argument :) You're right about the principle, of course. I just think it would be "10% pointless", and thus well worth doing.
- comicjk 6y agoAnother way of making the point: we did COVID challenge trials on monkeys first, because their immune systems are a decent model for that 80-year-old human's. Well, a 30-year-old human is an even better model of an 80-year-old human. A challenge trial on young people wouldn't prove everything, but it would give a high-information signal quickly.