4 ms·
Coronavirus emerged in Italy earlier than thought, Italian study shows
- petertodd 6y agoThe headline overstates it: antibodies reactive to the virus were found earlier than expected. But not the virus itself. That may mean that the virus was spreading earlier than thought. It may mean a closely related virus was spreading that generated cross-reactive antibodies (which we already know is happening with different antibodies). It may mean that COVID-19 was spreading, but later mutated into something more virulent. We just don't know yet.
- DoingIsLearning 6y agoWith the risk of repeating Sagan's "Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence", is it feasible at all that these results could be due to contamination/measurement/analysis error?
- petertodd 6y agoI'm no expert on the biology. But AFAIK there's no _universal_ contamination source that would be screwing up all these tests, as they're various forms of antibody reactivity tests. This isn't like PCR testing where trace amounts of the virus cause false positives. OTOH, as I said, it certainly doesn't prove by itself that the antibodies came from COVID infections.
- jjeaff 6y agoWasn't there also a case of old samples from a sewer system in Italy having sars-cov-2? I read that it could have been an error as well, bit never heard if there was a follow-up.
- vfclists 6y agoSo the virus may not have originated in China after all, unless the participants in the trial visited China or had contacts with people from China. Hmmmm. Interesting
- runawaybottle 6y agoDo we know for a fact where the other coronaviruses originated?
- aaron695 6y ago> signaling that it might have spread beyond China earlier than thought. That's the logical conclusion is it? Journal Article - https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0300891620974755 https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0300891620974755 It didn't come from the Wuhan markets. That was always simplistic rubbish. You would logically guess it was in rural China for months before. This is where it might bite us, if we looked wider than the mystical wet markets of the orient we might have understood how it spreads much sooner. But one study has the flaw it only has one group of researchers. I wouldn't believe it yet.
- najarvg 6y agoYes, you are right to be skeptical. It is an extraordinary claim that goes against all of what we know from covid-19 genome sequence studies so far. The burden of proof is very high for follow up evidence, otherwise it is just a hypothesis. Here is some commentary about this from the director at UCL Genetics Institute - https://twitter.com/BallouxFrancois/status/1328058398517190656 https://twitter.com/BallouxFrancois/status/13280583985171906... if anyone is interested in following along