4 ms·
Freedom of association is a right covered by the 1st Amendment as interpreted by the US Supreme Court. You have a right to go to the Town Square and voice your
by XorNot 6y ago
Freedom of association is a right covered by the 1st Amendment as interpreted by the US Supreme Court.
You have a right to go to the Town Square and voice your views if people want to listen, you don't have a right to do the same in a Wendy's.
- ashtonkem 6y agoAnd being forced to associate with someone by the government is just as tyrannical as being forced to not associate with someone by the government.
- arrosenberg 6y agoThat really depends on what you mean by “forced to associate”. You live in the same country, some association may be unavoidable.
- ashtonkem 6y agoThat's such a broad definition of both "force" and "associate", I'm inclined to call this a bad faith argument. No reasonable definition of "forced to associate" in the context of governmental power has anything to do with happening to live in the same country as someone you dislike.
- cortesoft 6y ago"Forced to associate" in this case means requiring a private company to host content it doesn't agree with.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mrslave 6y ago> You have a right to go to the Town Square and voice your views if people want to listen, you don't have a right to do the same in a Wendy's. But what about when the town square has moved on-line? Let's say it's not Wendy's IRL, but wendys.com. This is now a public space where people talk. And on top of this, people who don't like what you have to say aren't following you and don't have to listen to you anyway. Perhaps these websites are rather like a pub. People mostly go there in a group of friends, obviously are more likely to exchange with similar people or people with similar ideas, but there are other people there too having their own fun in a social setting. Occasionally very different people also exchange, sometimes politely, but sometimes not. But until fists are thrown, the publican isn't looking to kick anyone out. Sometimes the best exchanges are disagreeing people discussing in good faith, if that's what they're in the mood for. Sometimes they're just polite enough to talk about something they do agree on, rather than call for other people to be banned just because they're unpopular.
- XorNot 6y agoThe town square is defined by being the town square i.e. paid for, operated by and maintained by the government as a public space for the public. So any example you come up with which doesn't start with "service provided by the government for the public benefit" doesn't apply. And pub's definitely don't apply since they've long been able to eject anyone for pretty much any reason they want. So no, services provided by private companies, on their privately owned infrastructure, are not "public spaces for discussion".