4 ms·
What does this mean for the United States? Have countries abandoned the idea of uniting against China? Was this Trump's doing? What about TPP?
by echelon 6y ago
What does this mean for the United States?
Have countries abandoned the idea of uniting against China?
Was this Trump's doing?
What about TPP?
- tuatoru 6y agoTPP was replaced by the "Comprehensive and Progressive Trans-Pacific Partnership" (CPTPP) between Mexico, Canada, Australia, NZ, Japan, Singapore and (if they ratified it) Viet Nam, Malaysia, Brunei Dar es-Salaam, Peru and Chile. This is some of the same countries, but lots of other ones too (all the members of ASEAN). India was in this new one until last year when they got cold feet about reducing tariffs on milk and meat products. The main points are standardising goods classifications, paperwork, and procedures at point of import. This simplifies things a lot for exporters. There is some loosening of restrictions on services exports (I guess things like insurance, finance, business services, software) also. For the United States, it continues a slow marginalisation in world trade. Unless the US harmonises its rules with everyone else, it'll be too much bother to try to export there. Uniting against China... Here's an accurate if unsparing description of the US: "a crisis-wracked, oil-rich, nuclear-armed country in which an aging would-be dictator for life tries to stave off replacement by his popular successor amid large protests, while heavily armed groups roam the ethnically divided interior". China looks like a model of stability and calm by comparison. Edit: I forgot to attribute the quote: Kenyan comedian Gathara.
- xref 6y ago> Here's an accurate if unsparing description of the US: "a crisis-wracked, oil-rich, nuclear-armed country in which an aging would-be dictator for life tries to stave off replacement by his popular successor amid large protests, while heavily armed groups roam the ethnically divided interior". >China looks like a model of stability and calm by comparison. Isn’t Xi effectively dictator for life now, and not simply a “would be” like in the US? Doesn’t China have the 4th largest nuclear stockpile? (US is #2) Doesn’t China have the 12th largest proven oil reserves? (US is #10) Do the tens of thousands arrested/wounded/dead in Hong Kong count as “crisis wracked”? Doesn’t China ethnically divide itself between the Han vs everyone else, culturally erasing groups like the Tibetans or simply rounding up Uyghurs to fill concentration camps?
- dirtyid 6y agoDictators can be stabilizing especially if they prioritize calm and stability, which Xi / current 5 year plan does. Xi's entire socialist modernization scheme is supposed to continue until 2035, so we know China at least wants stable external environment for that long. Ranking hides context. China plans to double nuclear stockpile to around 600, but that's still 10% of what US current has at 6,000. Charitably 15% because US is slated to reduce stockpile to 3,800. China is a massive oil importer whereas US fracking makes it a net producer. This means China _must_ maintain SLOCs and maritime trade, whereas US has incentive to disrupt it. XJ/HK/Tibet can protest and it would be a relatively minor disruption because they account for ~1% of the population, the disruption in HKs case is only because anglosphere is making it a geopolitical issue. HK under NSL has moved _up_ Global Finance Centre Index this year, overtaking Singapore. Stability is good for business. And as Singapore demonstrates, one party systems is fine for long term financial prosperity. XJ had terrorism, but that's completely suppressed by the security architecture. Compared to US prison industrial complex, even if China jails every Uyghur rather than the alleged 1M+ right now, lifetime likelihood of being detained for Chinese Muslims (total population 80M) would be less than US Blacks at 28%. Rising pork prices is more of a concern of CCP than minority protests. Incidentally, food security and dependency on oil / resource imports is broadly why China benefits massively from global stability and existence of multilateral systems. Whereas US is largely self sufficient and can step back and watch the world burn. Ultimately, China needs stability, whereas US doesn't. Indeed US can afford to disrupt stability for everyone else, perhaps even sufficiently so at US relative gain.
- rdsubhas 6y agoYes. China has issues, but it's consistent. US is inconsistent. One year it's a messenger of trade and peace. Another year it's an anti-trade anti-peace rambler. Of course, other democracies have similar issues. But none are as sharply polarized as the US forced two-party system, where the objective of each party is to run on a platform to undo the other. The policy ping pong has probably reached it's extremes, so much that you cannot expect any kind of continuity anymore. With the exit of US from global stage and it's lack of continuity, other countries have to cope up to a new center of gravity.
- CountSessine 6y agoUS trade policy has actually been quite consistent over the last 20 years, which is to mitigate the damage caused by WTO noncompliance. The foreign policy community in Washington, right and left, have largely given up on the WTO but have had tolerate its continued existence mostly because of captured interests in the US. That’s over. Trump ripped off the bandaid. Those WTO appellate judges - whose appointments Obama blocked and Trump continued to block - will never sit and rule. The days of truly multilateral trade negotiations are over and right and the left in the US are in agreement over this.
- rdsubhas 6y agoThis is not about WTO. Iran, TPP, NAFTA, Paris Agreement, Korea free trade agreement (KORUS), ... There is a very long list. I believe it goes both sides on both parties, but what is there today is what is relevant to countries today. No country is going to look back at the "great old times" of USA as the benchmark for today's decisions. We can cook up a reason for each, and pretend the senate is a happy body working together in the spirit of democracy on foreign policy and trade. But reality is, other nations cannot and do not treat US as a role model for foreign policy continuity anymore.
- CountSessine 6y agoYou don’t get it. The WTO was the landmark achievement in US foreign and economic policy of the 1990’s and until recently was emblematic of US engagement with the rest of the world. US foreign and economic policy have actually been exceptionally consistent up until very recently. Every one of the issues you brought up - NAFTA, TPP, the Paris agreement - these were all ripped up during Trump’s term. But remember that it was Lighthizer and co who gave Trump the scissors. Other nations can think whatever they want about “US [...] foreign policy continuity” and can find whatever role models they like. The US just isn’t playing anymore - they neither aspire to nor are interested in being such a role model and the truth is that the rest of the world needs them a great deal more than they need it. Multilateralism is dead in Washington and the US will continue to engage with the world, but piecemeal and one country at a time. Anyone can opt out, but it means foregoing the biggest consumer market in the world and the largest and most efficient finance markets in the world.