2 ms·
I assume this is working under the presumption that we get rid of the voting software that already exists? This is a big part of OP's question, but I'll enterta
by godelski 6y ago
I assume this is working under the presumption that we get rid of the voting software that already exists? This is a big part of OP's question, but I'll entertain it.
You have to look at the 2000 election[0] where there was a switch to digital means. I don't have exact numbers, but I am under the impression that these machines are easier to use and are less error prone than the previous punch card methods. Your digital machines can also print you a receipt. So "why have a (digital) voting machine at all" is because it is easier and less error prone. Having election results going to the Supreme Court is a pretty big deal and should be avoided.
[0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2000_United_States_presidential_election#Voting_machines https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2000_United_States_presidentia...
- chrisseaton 6y agoBut yet again... you're talking about it relative to an alternative like punch machines... how about no machines.
- godelski 6y agoI mean if we're calling a punch ballot a machine then I think a check mark constitutes a machine. Pencil, pen, hole punch, what's the difference? It is a mark on a physical piece of paper. I think you're trying to work your solution into being correct rather than recognizing that the problem itself is extremely complicated. Given your other comments and our other conversations it is clear that you're overly simplifying the subject matter and frankly you are wrong about certain aspects of it (like that all votes are counted the night of rather than "enough"). If you flat out ignore these parts of the problem then you're going to get the wrong result. You should also not start with a solution and work towards an explanation, but rather work the other way around. These conversations feel really disingenuous to be honest. They feel more like they are based on how the UK is so much better without any real justification.
- ploika 6y ago> Pencil, pen, hole punch, what's the difference? It is a mark on a physical piece of paper Hanging chads? You even brought up the 2000 election in the US yourself. Pencil and paper (and no machines) would have avoided that mess.
- godelski 6y agoThe punch card was brought about because it was more reliable than a pen and paper where marks are routinely inconsistent. This isn't a UI team where people are just changing the format willy nilly, they are making these changes for legitimate reasons. Sometimes the "simpler" solution isn't as simple and reliable as one would think from just guessing. They actually test this stuff and seek more reliable solutions. Sure, it is slow to implement the new solutions, but that doesn't mean it is less reliable than the previous one. So please stop just guessing.
- Spooky23 6y agoInstead of having a machine reading ballots in a consistent way, you’ll have humans applying subjective judgement and fighting it.
- godelski 6y agoHumans who are subjective and have a dog in the race.