2 ms·
What a big Big Sur-prise! It's disturbing to see an OS update seemingly do something with the BIOS to render the machine completely inoperable. I wonder if the
by userbinator 6y ago
What a big Big Sur-prise!
It's disturbing to see an OS update seemingly do something with the BIOS to render the machine completely inoperable. I wonder if the EFI firmware on Macs is just as fragile as some PCs, and something like this happened: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11008449 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11008449
If that was what happened, and you were living in a place like Shenzhen, there's a chance you could simply go to one of the many repair shops around and have the BIOS reflashed in a few minutes while you wait, for <$10USD, and be back to working again.
Of course, Apple is heavily anti-right-to-repair and this might not even be an option in the future... and naturally, the reasons they give are "for security" -- securing their profits, that is.
The other is the overall "opaqueness" of Apple products, which reminds me of this classic Douglas Adams quote: "The major difference between a thing that might go wrong and a thing that cannot possibly go wrong is that when a thing that cannot possibly go wrong goes wrong it usually turns out to be impossible to get at or repair."
- comex 6y agoIt's common for macOS updates to also update EFI and other firmware. My guess is that there's some sort of bug with either the new firmware or the firmware update process… as opposed to EFI state somehow being corrupted while updating unrelated parts of the OS (which is what happened in your link). These days, Windows automatically installs firmware updates as well. The old PC status quo, where most users would never receive firmware updates at all, does have the advantage of avoiding issues like this. But it also has many disadvantages, including security risks.
- userbinator 6y agoThese days, Windows automatically installs firmware updates as well. Do you have any references for this? Because that is truly scary. I've heard of isolated instances of the manufacturer-installed crapware silently trying to update the BIOS in the background, failing, and resulting in bricked machines upon the next boot, but that wasn't Microsoft's doing. including security risks That is BS, unless you are talking about things like user-hostile "secure" boot, which are firmly in the area of "do not want" anyway.
- vondur 6y agoJust the other day I was updating a lab full of Dell Windows PC's and to my surprise, they received a firmware update view Windows update.
- justinclift 6y ago> These days, Windows automatically installs firmware updates as well. This happened to me. On a (primarily) Linux PC, I was having trouble with a game via Wine/Proton and thought I'd give Win10 a shot. Installed Win10 to a separate HDD, activated it, and (completely) disconnected it from the Net. Worked fine for a few days (weeks?) but then one day it announced it was installing a BIOS update. Without asking. And no way to Cancel that or somehow tell it to "DO NOT DO THIS". Note - At no point had it had an internet connection after it was activated. So the BIOS update must have been downloaded and scheduled at that time. This totally trashed my main Linux install, which uses full disk encryption and custom MOK certificates for booting. Not Happy. That being said, I have reasonable backups. So it was more of an incredulous PITA and reminder that "MS can go fuck themselves", than a data loss event.
- xodice 6y agoMy wife's Dell gaming laptop just installed a BIOS/Firmware update today, straight from Windows Update. Surprised me to see the firmware update after doing a reboot from updates.