3 ms·
Er -- philosophy is not science. It's outside of science. So it cannot be wrong. It either is more or less appropriate for various circumstances (just like scie
by DanielBMarkham 18y ago
Er -- philosophy is not science. It's outside of science. So it cannot be wrong. It either is more or less appropriate for various circumstances (just like science, but we won't go there)
So Hegel is not wrong. Heck, Freud and Marx weren't even scientific, so they really can't be wrong either.
I know what you're saying -- we wouldn't take time in chemistry to go over alchemy -- but there is a difference between a person, a time, and the best way of thinking for that time and the current state of the scientific model. Lots of times we can use heuristics and methods of thinkers who ended up in wrong spots in current problems. Likewise, not being aware of old ad beaten-to-death canards like Marxism means we end up going over the same old ground again.
Or looking at it from another angle: wouldn't you want to remember Carl Sagan a thousand years from now? Even if he appeared no smarter than a primitive cave man worshiping the sun? You see, everybody wants to throw away the old guys -- they're so obviously wrong. It's much harder to take the good with the bad.
To ignore thinkers from another age because the current scientific belief has changed deprives the current generation of everything else those thinkers had -- their powers of deduction, observation of human nature, the ability to put various disparate pieces together in synthesis, etc. It's throwing the baby out with the bath water. Over and over again we see thinkers trashed and the later parts of what they had turn out to be extremely useful. Plato missed the boat in certain ways, but who the heck could predict forms would turn into OOAD?
This is not a boolean question. (to quote another dis-remembered scientist who eventually gave us something useful) In most human affairs, there is a give and take of ideas, a dialectic. But there I go again.
- pg 18y agoIt's outside of science. So it cannot be wrong. p and ~p
- DanielBMarkham 18y ago"Wrong" does not apply to extra-scientific statements. "Ice Cream is nice" is extra-scientific. It is, strictly speaking, nonsense. "There might be a methodology for association various ice creams with personal tastes, and this methodology might hold up to the scientific method" is the beginning of an area of study for science. Philosophy generates science -- it moves from quasi-true and tenuous connective statements into fields of further study that can be joined with better-defined and more rigorous logic. Hegel made some great observations. Some of which are provable and might involve some creation of a scientific discipline at some time, and some not. Some were along the lines of "ice cream is nice". Since nonsensical statements have no logical evaluation, any formation of predicate logic is non-applicable. Or maybe I missed something. Seemed like you were being flip.
- IsaacSchlueter 18y agoWhat do you mean by "scientific"? It seems like you mean "propositional". "Ice cream is nice" is not nonsensical. It falls into a category of utterances that actually say something about the speaker rather than the thing indicated. "Nice" is shorthand for "deemed by the speaker to be of high value". It can definitely be true or false. However, due to the clever formulation, if I disagree with you, and say "Ice cream is not nice," I'm not really disagreeing with you, but rather stating something about myself. That's not to say that there's no such thing as nonsense statements. But, to the extent that you're really doing philosophy and not just making word salad, philosophy has no place for nonsense.
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoI'd point out that some of Popper's criticism of what science is and what sciences isn't was based on a response to Marxism, which was wondrously flexible enough to handle any sort of new information without changing its underlying beliefs.
- mlinsey 18y agoYou're using the word "philosophy" in it's everyday sense. My life philosophy might be to take risks, live it to the fullest, and enjoy ice cream, because ice cream is nice. Those are extra-scientific statements. Philosophy, the discipline taught in academic departments, is something else entirely. It's a bit ironic that you contrasted philosophy to "better-defined and more rigorous logic", because the formal study logic is a sub-discipline of philosophy. At least at my college, if you're a math major and want to learn about logic, you take a course listed in the Philosophy department. Now, sometimes philosophy does rest on premises which are either extra-scientific or which should be scientifically testable but are not proven rigorously by a philosopher. For example, I could make an argument about whether or not free will is compatible with determinism. In doing so I might make some assumptions about "free will" and the nature of mind which probably should be sanity-checked by a neuroscientist sometime down the road. But those are just problems with my assumptions: whether or not my argument is good Philosophy depends on how well I make the argument, in other words whether it is valid, in the technical sense of the term. Hagel and other Continental Philosophers get a bad rap for being light on rigor, and we can have a whole separate debate about that, but to say that philosophy consists of quasi-true statements that can't be logically evaluated is just insane. (I'd be particularly interested in which of Hegel's arguments you thought were "nonsensical" or "along the lines of ice cream is nice"! Although I admit I only have any familiarity with Philosophy of Right, anything I know about his other works is secondhand)