4 ms·
Is there a better source? I'd like to know what gene they added and if there is any reason to believe that could have been an evolutionary step. Gene's dont app
by phkahler 6y ago
Is there a better source? I'd like to know what gene they added and if there is any reason to believe that could have been an evolutionary step. Gene's dont appear whole out of nowhere. Was it an extra copy of an existing gene? A mutation and duplication? Some weird replication error?
- carbocation 6y agoThe source is this article: https://science.sciencemag.org/content/369/6503/546 https://science.sciencemag.org/content/369/6503/546 The gene is ARHGAP11B under the control of its usual human-specific promoter.
- phkahler 6y agoI found another article that covers the origin of the gene here: https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2020/06/200618150301.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2020/06/200618150301.h...
- shmageggy 6y agoI'm also curious about all the related morphological changes that must go along with increased brain size, such as different proportions of the skull and face and wider hips on females to accommodate birth. It seems unlikely one gene can modulate all of those, let alone yield the social structures required for increased rearing time.
- keithwhor 6y agoDevelopmental biology has a whole lot of plasticity and works primarily by self-organization of cell populations. It’s not a computer program where you have to allocate memory for skulls, eyes, ears and more — it’s actually more like a population of organisms that align themselves towards specific goals (“hey team, we need a hand — now time for fingers! You guys in the middle, die off!”) You can think of a gene for i.e. brain size just being an instruction that’s “you can press harder on the other populations to maximize your growth” and the other populations are likely to accommodate the stress during development, and change size and shape accordingly. There are of course harmful mutations that are unable to be compensated for and lead to failure to thrive, but when you see a successful morphological mutation it’s because the systems are very adept at integrating new stimulus during growth. (Similarly, social structures are emergent properties as well.)