4 ms·
I'm curious what you're referring to specifically, since there is incredibly sharp film footage out there. Are you talking about resolution from film grain? Be
by crazygringo 6y ago
I'm curious what you're referring to specifically, since there is incredibly sharp film footage out there.
Are you talking about resolution from film grain? Because 35mm film is generally to be considered a good bit higher resolution than 4K.
Or the noise properties of film grain, which is a separate issue from resolution? Which shows up some in well-lit conditions, but is even more obvious in nighttime shots? That's certainly easy to add.
Or are you talking about lower-quality lenses (e.g. chromatic abberation), or focus issues?
Or something else? I don't know at all what you mean by the "aliasing and sharpening" that you claim professional digital cameras perform. (Since we're not talking about iPhone camera processing, but rather the cameras movies and broadcasters use.)
- simias 6y agoAnalog support doesn't sample individual pixels in a grid format. That's why it's rather meaningless to talk about the resolution of analog photos or video, the actually information density will vary depending on a large number of factors and may not even be the same depending on what you measure. For instance old school analog TV had significantly more information in the lumas than in the chroma. And then you have old school lenses vs. modern lenses and many other factors. I agree with the parent that the end result is an amusing novelty but if the intention was to fool me into thinking that it was actually an ancient recording I don't think I would've fallen for it. It's too sharp, the blurring effect on movement feel wrong too and the dynamics are off I think (film has amazing contrast that digital sensors still struggle to emulate).
- schrijver 6y ago> For instance old school analog TV had significantly more information in the lumas than in the chroma. That’s the case for the large majority of digital content as well, in a codec like H264 the chroma resolution is a quarter of the luma resolution. > but if the intention was to fool me into thinking that it was actually an ancient recording To be fair, no one claimed this. I think it’s almost impossible to do because so many factors come together.
- crazygringo 6y agoSure, but I wouldn't go so far as to say resolution of analog is "meaningless". I'm not aware of a precise quantitative measure of film "resolution", but simply from a qualitative sense of resolving detail, it's quite meaningful and useful to say that 35mm film is generally considered to lie somewhere between 4K and 8K. Which is far higher than 1080p. In other words, if you're watching a 1080p video and complaining it appears too "high-resolution" to have been transferred from film, that's almost certainly incorrect, and it's something else that cluing you in it wasn't film -- probably grain and/or color characteristics.
- pessimizer 6y agoIsn't the opposite the case? If I see aliasing and sharpening, I see it as digital distortion you wouldn't expect from film. When I see a bunch of digital artifacts on a film transfer, I think of it as a bad transfer.
- crazygringo 6y agoIf it's overly sharp, yes. But most commercial video footage isn't digitally sharpened, for a host of reasons (mainly that it usually looks bad, harms more than it helps). So high resolution doesn't mean sharpening has been applied. If it came from film, it just means the film had that level of detail to begin with.
- EvanAnderson 6y agoFor home movies, at least, 8mm and Super 8mm was a very common format. An 8mm frame has a lot less resolution than 35mm. Kodachrome and Ektachrome film have very identifiable artifacts, too.
- joshuak 6y agoI've done A-list visual effects work since the 90s, and I can say that film for motion picture production[1] varies widely in it's grain density and size. This variation is amplified by the fact that DPs often "push" or "pull" the stock which means they treat it as if it was a different ISO speed than labeled (exposure and lab processing change to compensate). In practical application digital elements nearly always have to be reduced in effective resolution to match film plates when composited. Of course under laboratory conditions using larger negative size (like 65mm), Velvia or some other extraordinary film stock you can of course produce extremely high resolution individual frames, but as we know from a lifetime of movies this is neither practical nor necessary. Though a great source of religious wars. However, there is a reason why film's "lower resolution" still produces superior resolving power... Every single frame of film has a different randomized set of sample points. This in combination with human persistence of vision[2] and our ability to see pattern but discard noise means that a static shot on film is significantly more resolved in our minds after only a few frames than the equivalent shot recorded by color filter array[3]. It's not just perceptual, temporal sampling truly produces a more accurate representation of the image content over time. This is a fascinating quality of film that can give you the sense of graininess and low quality while still producing superior image detail in your mind, but as soon as you stop the projector and evaluate the film image by image the effect is lost. You might be left wondering where did all that detail go? [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_motion_picture_film_stocks https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_motion_picture_film_st... [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Persistence_of_vision https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Persistence_of_vision [3]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Color_filter_array https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Color_filter_array
- systemvoltage 6y agoSorry, I am not well educated in this area to precisely define the “resolution”. Perhaps it’s film grain or the smoothness of the edges.