3 ms·
I wonder if making a shell on top of Android (for compatiblity with other devices) would make community larger and get more software contributions. Not sure how
by izacus 6y ago
I wonder if making a shell on top of Android (for compatiblity with other devices) would make community larger and get more software contributions. Not sure how technically feasible it is though.
- slothtrop 6y agoMaybe, though in the worst case there's Anbox emulation.
- mook 6y agoWasn't FirefoxOS (the defunct phone one, now there's the KaiOS fork) sort of like that? I believe Gonk took some parts from Android, but haven't dug into it. Given that example, not sure how feasible the app ecosystem is.
- josteink 6y agoFirefoxOS tried to ride on an Android-base to help solve device-support and being able to focus on the user-facing aspects of the platform. As a result they were stuck with a combination of the terrible Android-build system and the complex Firefox build-system. That alone probably wasn't the reason it failed, but it certainly didn't help people who wanted to contribute (like me).
- josteink 6y ago> I wonder if making a shell on top of Android (for compatiblity with other devices) would make community larger But then it would just be another Google-phone, based on a Google-controlled codebase. We have enough of those phones and "OSes" already. I respect the Pine64, PinePhone and the surrounding communities for trying to make an actual, real Linux-phone based on a real Linux base. I even bought a PinePhone myself to play with. It's definitely not there yet in terms a full replacement of my iPhone, but at the same time I can see all the pieces starting to come together: It's a real phone, with an open bootloader, running real Linux (with systemd, PulseAudio, whatever your distro rolls with) and a custom shell made for touchscreen phones. It's just what it needs to be. It just lacks some polish, that's all. And the community feels really vibrant, akin to the early Linux hacker-scene you had back in the 90s, where everyone is trying to do their part to help deliver something new and different. For better, it's like a full deja back to those days. I love it!
- squarefoot 6y agoPretty much all Linux installs on Android phones are chroot jails on top of Android. They run at decent speed because everything is native, but they're forced to use Android's kernel and device drivers which are non free, closed and therefore not trustworthy, and cannot protect themselves by malicious Android apps and/or backdoors. I would rather have a truly free and open operating system in which I can set up one or more sandboxes containing all stuff I don't trust (closed apps, Android emulation etc), that is essentially the other way around. The Pinephone ideally is trying to be a step in this direction.
- qiqitori 6y ago> Android's kernel and device drivers which are non free, closed and therefore not trustworthy That's a bit misleading. Android's kernel is Linux which is GPLv2, and thus the device drivers are GPLv2 too. (They could be circumventing the GPL by using shims though.)
- izacus 6y agoI think you perhaps misunderstood me - it's not to replace the PinePhone implementation, but to complement it. Give users the ability to boot PinePhone software to both try it out (so they see it's good enough to replace their current Android phone) and to make filling up the software gaps easier. All while open hardware continues to be developed. Right now, PinePhone development requires a pretty expensive buyin with pretty much no ability to see it ahead of time.