12 ms·
macOS Big Sur Update Bricking Some Older MacBook Pro Models
- RyckP 6y agoReading here about bricked MBPs. Could someone clarify for me. If one swaps out the SSD with the current OS and puts in a blank replacement and then do the update. If it fails will the MBP be bricked or can one just swap in the other SSD to get it operational with the older OS. Or can the update really brick it because hardware is flashed? If that's the case could that be re-flashed by someone with the right equipment and knowledge. Some people have upgraded to Big Sur on their 2011 and mid 2012 MBPs. What is the risk of bricking then?
- melling 6y agoMy 2010 27” iMac got bricked a few upgrades ago. I’d like to wait until the second ARM cycle before upgrading my 2013 MBP. I miss being able to pull a CD off the shelf and doing a fresh install.
- dangus 6y agoYou can do a clean install on modern Macs using USB media: https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT201372 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT201372
- stephenr 6y agoWhat’s more you can setup multiple versions of the installer on one drive and it’ll show you the installer icon for each one at the boot select screen (I can’t say I’ve added Big Sur to my installer drive but the previous three work this way)
- limeblack 6y agoFor vintage products, restoring to factory settings often has to be done through torrents or Github. Other then that no complaints.
- Kwpolska 6y agoHow vintage is vintage? Internet Recovery was added in 2011 [0] — although it doesn’t work in all cases. If you have older hardware (as old as 2007), you can download Yosemite, El Capitan or Sierra from Apple’s website [1] or the App Store. Note that using those images requires access to a working Mac, or at least a Mac with working (Internet) Recovery, although doing it in Recovery is complicated and requires some tricks [2], because Apple can’t just make a simple DMG you could mount (or image a drive with) and install directly. [0]: https://9to5mac.com/2011/07/20/what-is-os-x-lion-internet-recovery-and-how-does-it-work/ https://9to5mac.com/2011/07/20/what-is-os-x-lion-internet-re... [1]: https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT211683 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT211683 [2]: https://chriswarrick.com/blog/2020/06/03/reinstalling-macos-what-to-try-when-all-else-fails/#making-install-media-with-el-capitan-with-access-only-to-recovery https://chriswarrick.com/blog/2020/06/03/reinstalling-macos-...
- tinus_hn 6y agoOr even from the internet with no media at all.
- bitL 6y agoNot if you want to downgrade your OS version.
- ValentineC 6y agoDo you mind elaborating? I've upgraded my late 2013 MacBook Pro to Catalina, then downgraded back to Mojave just fine.
- bitL 6y agoDidn't Mojave convert HFS+ to APFS? I don't think that would work with (High) Sierra or older.
- dangus 6y ago> it is unclear exactly how many users of these models have been affected An unknown percentage of millions of a particular product have failed, news at 11. Seriously, I don’t know what anyone is supposed to take out of articles like this. If you don’t back up your stuff all bets are off, regardless of what device you own or whether you even decide to upgrade the software on it.
- blindm 6y ago> If you don’t back up your stuff all bets are off Yes I always plan ahead incase the OS becomes corrupted. I just assume that an OS will fail at some stage, and I have prepared so many times setting up a new OS from scratch I could nearly do it blindfolded. The trick is to 'rehearse' a clean install of an OS repeatedly so that it doesn't feel so harrowing when it does fail (and I've had plenty of actual crashes over the course of my daily computing adventures, covering different OSes like Linux, macOS, Windows).
- buzzerbetrayed 6y agoDespite the downvote, I 100% agree with you. I reinstall my OS every couple years it seems like. Because of this practice, I can have my laptop destroyed at any time and it won't matter to me at all, besides the cost of the hardware. The only thing I would lose at all is any unpushed code, which is only a couple hours of work at most. It is great to have a setup like this, as I am reminded any time someone I know has a hard drive failure and is freaking out about it.
- Fnoord 6y ago> The trick is to 'rehearse' a clean install of an OS repeatedly so that it doesn't feel so harrowing when it does fail (and I've had plenty of actual crashes over the course of my daily computing adventures, covering different OSes like Linux, macOS, Windows). A tool like Ansible, Nix, or Docker Compose is useful in such situations.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- 6y ago
- lights0123 6y agoIt looks like the I/O board is the issue: https://discussions.apple.com/thread/252033190?answerId=253881862022#253881862022 https://discussions.apple.com/thread/252033190?answerId=2538...
- mmastrac 6y agoThis will be an interesting postmortem. Perhaps the EFI firmware contained incompatible firmware for this HDMI chip? Or maybe removing it bypasses a buggy bit of firmware?
- tpush 6y agoSpeaking of UEFI, does anyone know if Apple still uses UEFI in the DTK or M1 chip Macs?
- Gaelan 6y agoI believe folks have said no.
- madaxe_again 6y agoI’d assume it’s different in the 15” late 2013 machines, as I upgraded today without issue - although there was about a five minute interlude of a completely black screen, during which I can only assume it was doing whatever it does to the IO board that bricks the 13” models.
- spuz 6y agoThe poster says the update somehow broke their IO IC. That seems unlikely. It's more likely that the update includes new firmware for that chip which contains a bug. In theory, when Apple identify the cause they can update their software so this won't happen for future upgrades. In the meantime, I'm sure they can offer compensation to those with bricked devices who can choose to either put that towards a new computer or send it in for repair.
- xenonite 6y agoDoes anyone know how to downgrade the firmware of my Macbook Pro 15" (2014)? I ran the Big Sur Beta 1 with it on an external SSD drive. Since then, the standby mode on the internally installed macOS 10.11 does not work anymore. At some point, the system freezes while the fans spin on full speed, indefinitely until powering down with a long-press of the eject key.
- peterburkimsher 6y agoThank you so much for warning me: I have the same model (2014 MBP 15"), and would very likely have tested booting an external drive with another OS, not expecting it to cause harm to my hardware. Maybe this will help; the instructions are for Yosemite though. https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/guide-how-to-get-back-old-efi-after-downgrade-from-yosemite.1803934/ https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/guide-how-to-get-back-o...
- xenonite 6y agoThank you very much for your hint. So far, it seems that the downgrade did not succeed. The boot ROM number is still the same after the manual patch.
- deeblering4 6y agoI’m curious, why do people jump onto a new OS release as soon as it becomes available? Especially on machines they are using professionally. Between bugs in the OS itself, bugs in apps, and developers who lag behind on OS support (looking at you DAW and audio plug-in devs) it will probably be a year before I try this upgrade myself.
- throwaway201103 6y agoMaybe because your computer immediately starts nagging you to do it, and the messaging from the popular tech media is "stay up to date because hackerz"
- breakfastduck 6y agoI've not been nagged to upgrade once
- hahaiscjaaka 6y agoI drive every day and have never crashed my car. Therefore, car crashes are not real and cannot affect me.
- Nextgrid 6y agoSince Catalina the "softwareupdate --ignore" command no longer works unless you have an enterprise MDM profile installed, so you can't even work around that anymore.
- astronautjones 6y agoit's such nonsense, especially if you are even remotely computer literate. I'm working on an article about it, but I used snow leopard for 12 years with no ill effects (until this year!) and only finally left it because of the tyranny of HDCP
- mobilemidget 6y agoCuriosity mainly I guess. The update did take longer than indicated. At some points I wondered if both my iMac and mbp were not locked up, but as I was doing other things I just let them take their time. I wonder if those people rebooted mid update or some
- fbelzile 6y agoThere's really no excuse for this. How is it that Apple wants to tightly integrate their hardware and software but then seemingly miss testing major OS updates on all supported hardware? Apple needs to fix their QA, and fast. No amount of marketing can undo the damage I've seen over the last few years.
- p_l 6y agoThe same way that installer is broken for at least 5 or more years, hitting infinite loops resulting in users rebooting till finally upgrade or install passes through. Tight integration between OS and hw is mostly used to half-arse firmware interfaces, with huge amounts of "quirks" surfaced by hackintosh enthusiasts.
- bgorman 6y agoThis type of problem has been around for a decade. Once an Apple product is no longer produced, driver support completely falls by the wayside. There is simply no direct business value to make sure the update works well on all devices. I have a 2020 Intel Macbook Air and I am going to be extremely conservative upgrading to Big Sur, and in fact may not do it at all since Apple seems to support security updates for years on older releases.
- pmontra 6y agoMaybe there is no direct business value but maybe indirectly some of the people hit by this problem could wonder if they should buy their next laptop from a different manufacturer or advise their friend to do so. By the way my HP laptop from 2014 did well with every single Ubuntu LTS from 12.04 (I bought at the beginning of the year) to 20.04.
- rubicon33 6y agoMy Samsung Series 9 was bricked on it's first Ubuntu LTS update. Learned a hard lesson that day.
- 6y ago
- theobeers 6y agoOne of my current machines is a late 2013 13-inch MBP. No problems so far with Big Sur. Of course, my anecdata are no better or worse than anyone else’s.
- bitL 6y agoI managed to install Big Sur on an "unsupported" 15" retina 2012 using Patched-Sur.dmg without any issues, perhaps that's the way for 2013/14 ones as well now?
- vdfs 6y agoHow do you know those images don't have any malicious app? i have an older model but don't trust those patcher images/apps
- bitL 6y agoIt pulls the installation package directly from Apple. Source code is here if you want to inspect it: https://github.com/BenSova/Patched-Sur https://github.com/BenSova/Patched-Sur
- sccxy 6y agoYou can contact Apple support and they will kindly instruct you how to buy new MacBook Pro.
- chmaynard 6y agoI appreciate good snark. However, you get bonus points if you add something substantial to the discussion. For example, my advice is to avoid upgrading to a new OS without a backup that can be easily re-installed when the installation goes south.
- Craighead 6y agoMy advice is to start avoiding Apple
- harha 6y agoTrue, you should back up to avoid some strange edge case, but Apple markets itself as the company that makes using computers simpler and claims it works with the model. As a user I'd expect at the very least it not to systematically fail on a model that is intended to work. Also completely rolling back is much more difficult with the whole closed system issue (which is something users accept in return of simplicity), it's not like getting Ubuntu 18.04 LTS .
- m463 6y agoNow I sort of regret an apple store visit a year or two ago. A family member was in school and had a few-year-old macbook air that had a black screen. We took it to apple and they told me they could send it away to have it fixed for $700 or we could buy a new one for just a little more. And well, school. So we decided on the new one. And in for a penny, in for a pound. We had to keep going. We needed to upgrade, so we needed dongles. I think thunderbolt 2 cable + thunderbolt3 to tb2 dongle. and of course a tb3 to usb adapter. So power up the old machine (it still works), connect to new machine, upgrade over firewire and we're good. I should watch youtube and fix the old one. it has 2 regular usb ports + an sd card reader, so it's more useful. But I still have a bad taste in my mouth. $700 for a black screen? I think they really do raise the repair price all the way to a new one because they can.
- dlevine 6y agoI have a late 2013 Macbook Pro. This update bricked it. I have a tendency to install most Apple releases when they are first available, even though there are often problems that are usually fixed with a few updates. I'm sometimes able to boot into Internet Recovery mode (Command-Option-G). Unfortunately, it seems like the only option is to reinstall Big Sur, which doesn't fix the problem. Hopefully once Apple fixes this issue, I will be able to install the updated version and get it working again. If not, this machine is 7 years old and more or less on its last legs, but I'm still somewhat disappointed.
- peterburkimsher 6y agoI'm so sorry to hear it's bricked; thank you for warning me not to install the update on mine. Is yours a 13" model? I'd like to know if it breaks 15" models too. Are you able to boot with Shift-Option-⌘-R into Recovery Mode from an older version? https://support.apple.com/en-gb/HT204904 https://support.apple.com/en-gb/HT204904 What about Thunderbolt disk mode? (hold T at startup). Or booting from an external drive?
- mritun 6y agoAnecdote: I upgrade my late-2013 15” MBP to Big Sur without any issues. Feels a little bit snappier than Catalina for what’s it’s worth.
- userbinator 6y agoWhat a big Big Sur-prise! It's disturbing to see an OS update seemingly do something with the BIOS to render the machine completely inoperable. I wonder if the EFI firmware on Macs is just as fragile as some PCs, and something like this happened: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11008449 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11008449 If that was what happened, and you were living in a place like Shenzhen, there's a chance you could simply go to one of the many repair shops around and have the BIOS reflashed in a few minutes while you wait, for <$10USD, and be back to working again. Of course, Apple is heavily anti-right-to-repair and this might not even be an option in the future... and naturally, the reasons they give are "for security" -- securing their profits, that is. The other is the overall "opaqueness" of Apple products, which reminds me of this classic Douglas Adams quote: "The major difference between a thing that might go wrong and a thing that cannot possibly go wrong is that when a thing that cannot possibly go wrong goes wrong it usually turns out to be impossible to get at or repair."
- comex 6y agoIt's common for macOS updates to also update EFI and other firmware. My guess is that there's some sort of bug with either the new firmware or the firmware update process… as opposed to EFI state somehow being corrupted while updating unrelated parts of the OS (which is what happened in your link). These days, Windows automatically installs firmware updates as well. The old PC status quo, where most users would never receive firmware updates at all, does have the advantage of avoiding issues like this. But it also has many disadvantages, including security risks.
- userbinator 6y agoThese days, Windows automatically installs firmware updates as well. Do you have any references for this? Because that is truly scary. I've heard of isolated instances of the manufacturer-installed crapware silently trying to update the BIOS in the background, failing, and resulting in bricked machines upon the next boot, but that wasn't Microsoft's doing. including security risks That is BS, unless you are talking about things like user-hostile "secure" boot, which are firmly in the area of "do not want" anyway.
- mahesh_rm 6y ago..and, this is why I love HN. Stumbling into this likely allowing to avoid a big headache.
- newscracker 6y agoI know that every release of Mac OS X/OS X/macOS has had issues, but the last decade or so seems to be a huge downturn on the Mac hardware and the Mac OS by Apple. The Mac OS has truly become like Windows of the past, where upgrading to a new version is recommended only after SP1 (or even SP2). There are comments elsewhere that are just victim blaming and victim shaming the people who upgraded on seeing the prompt that comes up. Apple will, in its usual style, never admit to the issue nor offer free repair to the affected (bricking the HDMI chip seems to be the cause, as per some threads on Apple’s discussion forums). Apple has once again dropped the ball, and neither Tim Cook nor Craig Federighi seem eager on solving these problems, and during the current COVID-19 period, this is just unforgivable. For once, I’d like to see some senior executive in Apple publicly state “We’re sorry we messed up, we will make it right” and then do the right thing. That couldn’t even happen in a dream I suppose.
- finchisko 6y agothis is pitty, because as users might blame apple now. the outcome may be, apple dropping support for older device much earlier. which is bad for everybody.
- Hammershaft 6y agoAre you arguing that users should not blame Apple for pushing out an OS update that bricks customers computers?
- finchisko 6y agoNot at all. Just foreseeing the future.
- fattybob 6y agomy late-2013 15" mbp upgraded with no issues, but I do recall reading prior to I stalling and noting that any older, or smaller model of that age was not supported. most of the reports I've read seem ti concern the smaller model and I'm left wondering what did they expect?